Documented alternative currencies have included prison commissary packets, camp cigarettes, tea bricks, and stamped local notes, each with a clear limit.
The ten cases below are packaged mackerel in some prisons, cigarettes in prisoner-of-war camps, instant noodles as a later commissary money, Theresienstadt ghetto scrip, paper "bully marks" in a camp shop, tea bricks in Inner Asian trade, Ithaca HOURS, the Chiemgauer, a laundry detergent in some illicit resale markets, and the Wörgl experiment. This is a history of media of exchange that can be documented. It is not a guide to prison markets, theft, or evading a legal tender, and it will not copy official banknote or coin designs.
Key Facts
| Medium | What is documented | A limit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Packaged mackerel used as commissary currency in some prisons after smoking bans | A local, inside-the-walls money, not a cash substitute at the gate |
| 2 | Cigarettes becoming a unit of account in Second World War prison camps, as described by R. A. Radford | A camp economy, not a general theory that any shortage creates a currency |
| 3 | Instant noodles used as payment in a studied state prison | One sociological file, not every institution |
| 4 | Official scrip inside the Theresienstadt ghetto | A coercive and propagandistic medium, not a normal town currency |
| 5 | Paper "bully marks" issued in a camp shop, also in Radford's account | Confidence lasted only as long as the food behind the notes |
| 6 | Compressed tea traveling as a trade good and, in some places, as commodity money | A regional practice, not a single official mint |
| 7 | Ithaca HOURS, a voluntary local currency begun in 1991 | Organizers' trade totals should be read as reported figures |
| 8 | The Chiemgauer, a Bavarian regional currency with a built-in reason to spend | Pegged to the euro and limited to participating firms |
| 9 | A well-known laundry detergent reported as a resale and barter good in some illicit markets | A stolen commodity with a price, not a public street money |
| 10 | Wörgl's stamped work certificates in 1932 and 1933 | A short municipal experiment, later stopped by higher authorities |
1. Packaged Fish as an Inside Money
After smoking was banned in many United States federal prisons in the mid-2000s, cigarettes lost a role they had long played as an informal currency [1]. Reporting and later studies described packaged mackerel, often called "macks," taking some of that role: a commissary item with a known price, a long shelf life, and, for many people, a limited appeal as food, which made the pouch easier to hold as a store of value. Haircuts, small services, and debts could be priced in pouches. The value still moved when wholesale or commissary prices moved, and a locker of fish was not exchangeable for ordinary cash at release [1].
The unexpected fact is that a good can work as money partly because not everyone wants to eat it [1]. This article will not map a prison market or a list of illicit trades. The careful fact is a documented shift after a tobacco ban, a documented commissary staple, and a hard limit at the gate. A pouch can be a unit. It is still a fish in a packet, and only inside the walls.
A currency can be oily, portable, and unsellable the day a sentence ends. That limit is part of the definition.
2. Cigarettes as a Camp Unit of Account
The British economist R. A. Radford, writing from his own time as a prisoner of war, described how Red Cross parcels and camp trade quickly produced a price system in cigarettes [2]. Goods were advertised as so many cigarettes, even by people who did not smoke, because someone else would take them later. In that setting the cigarette was a medium of exchange, a unit of account, and, while stocks lasted, a store of value. Radford also noted that better smokes were more likely to be used, and thinner or worse ones more likely to be passed, a small case of better units leaving circulation [2].
The unexpected fact is how fast a unit can appear when a closed group shares a common, divisible good [2]. This article will not treat a prison camp as a cute classroom, and it will not display a brand. The careful fact is a documented first-hand economic paper, a documented role for the cigarette, and a reminder that the "market" existed inside captivity. The parcel was the supply. The price list was the improvisation.
A cigarette can be money in a camp and still be, outside that fence, only a ration item in a box.
3. Instant Noodles in a Studied Prison Economy
In later American prisons, instant noodles, often called "soups," have been described as a commissary currency [3]. The sociologist Michael Gibson-Light, after fieldwork in a large state prison, reported that packets were used to pay for food, small goods, and services, and that their rise was tied not only to tobacco rules but also to the appeal of a cheap, dense, durable food when official portions felt thin. A visible stash could signal that someone was doing relatively well inside the informal accounts of the place. This is one carefully reported institution, not a claim about every prison [3].
Related: Top 10 Most Bizarre Phobias: Strange Fears That Exist
The unexpected fact is that a money can remain edible and still circulate [3]. This article will not offer a commissary strategy. The careful fact is a documented sociological study, a documented use of the packet as payment, and a double life as food and as a token. If the informal economy tightened, the savings could still be cooked. That is a property of a commodity money, not a joke about a collapse.
A packet of noodles can be a wage inside a wall. It is still, at the bottom, a grocery item with a known commissary price.
4. Ghetto Scrip That Was Made to Look Like Ordinary Money
In 1943, Nazi authorities introduced a special paper money inside the Theresienstadt ghetto in occupied Czechoslovakia [4]. A ghetto bank and shops were part of a coerced internal economy, and the notes were also useful to a propaganda picture of a self-governing community. The place was a prison and a transit point, not a town that had chosen a currency. Many of those imprisoned there died of hunger and disease or were deported further. A separate informal trade in food and goods continued outside the official paper. The scrip "worked" only as an instrument inside that system [4].
The unexpected fact is that a note can circulate and still not be, in any ordinary sense, a free currency [4]. This article will not copy the design of the notes, will not restage suffering, and will not treat the bank as a curiosity of graphic art. The careful fact is a documented official issue, a documented propagandistic use, and a documented gap between the paper and the reality of the ghetto. Appearance was the point of the issue. Appearance was also the lie.
A currency can be printed for a place whose residents had already been stripped of ordinary rights. That is the fact that has to come first.
5. Paper Marks Backed by the Camp Shop
In the same world of camp trade that Radford described, organizers sometimes went a step further and issued paper tokens [5]. In one camp, a shop and an entertainments canteen used notes nicknamed bully marks, after the tinned beef in parcels, so that prices would not have to jump every time the cigarette supply jumped. The notes were supposed to be backed by food held in the shop, which is why they could not be printed at will. For a time they circulated beside cigarettes. When parcels were cut, the camp was damaged, and the canteen closed, people became less willing to give scarce food for paper, and the token faded [5].
The unexpected fact is that even a tiny paper money can have a central-bank problem: backing and confidence [5]. This article will not treat the episode as a board game. The careful fact is a documented shop currency, a documented link to food stocks, and a documented loss of trust when those stocks failed. The name is almost comic. The lesson is not.
Related: Top 10 Oldest Buildings in the World
A mark can be a tin of beef in disguise. When the tin is gone, the disguise is obvious.
6. Tea Bricks That Traveled as Goods, and Sometimes as Money
Compressed tea traveled for centuries from Chinese producing areas into Mongolia, Tibet, Siberia, and related trade routes [6]. The bricks were useful, relatively durable, and often marked by quality or origin. In some communities they were used not only as a drink and a trade good but as a unit that could settle a payment, a form of commodity money. Museum collections include bricks scored so that a smaller piece could be broken off, which would have made small transactions easier, though not every surviving brick is proof of a mint-like standard [6].
The unexpected fact is that a drink can be saved as a brick and still be, in a pinch, consumed [6]. This article will not invent a single official "tea standard" for a whole continent. The careful fact is a documented long-distance trade, documented local use as a medium, and a real limit: this was regional practice, not a universal currency. Intrinsic use is the backstop of a commodity money. The backstop, here, was a kettle.
A brick of tea can be wealth in a caravan and still be, if confidence fails, breakfast.
7. Ithaca HOURS, a Voluntary Local Note
In 1991, people in Ithaca, New York, began using a printed local currency called Ithaca HOURS, associated with Paul Glover [7]. One HOUR was at first treated as worth about ten dollars, a rough stand-in for an hour of ordinary local labor, and smaller denominations followed. Restaurants, trades, farms, and other participating businesses took the notes. Organizers later reported a large cumulative volume of trade; those figures are useful as an organizer's account, not as a central-bank audit. The notes were voluntary, were not copies of national currency, and income in them remained taxable. Their usefulness stopped, as intended, at the edge of a willing local network [7].
The unexpected fact is that a legal local money can exist beside a national one if it does not pretend to be the national one [7]. This article will not offer a kit for printing a town note. The careful fact is a documented community currency, documented participation, and a geographic limit that was the whole point. A dollar can leave town quickly. An HOUR was designed not to.
Related: 10 Sikh Gurus: The Pillars of Sikhism Who Shaped Faith, Equality, Courage, and Humanity
A local note can be ordinary in a cafe and still be, a county away, only a souvenir of a place that agreed to take it.
8. A Classroom Currency That Stayed in the Town
In 2003, the teacher Christian Gelleri and his students in Bavaria created the Chiemgauer as a lesson in how money works; local businesses and residents then kept it in use [8]. The unit was pegged to the euro and could be spent at participating firms in the region. Notes were designed to lose convenience if they sat unused, through a periodic stamp or similar demurrage feature, so that holding them was slightly costly and spending them was the easier path. Fees charged when businesses converted back into euros were used, in part, to support local groups. The currency remains a regional, voluntary complement, not a rival to the national money [8].
The unexpected fact is that a school exercise can become a standing local institution [8]. This article will not treat the stamp as a trick to copy. The careful fact is a documented origin in a classroom, a documented peg, a documented incentive to circulate, and a documented civic use of conversion fees. Speed was a design choice. The euro remained the anchor.
A regional note can be a lesson that forgot to end when the term ended.
9. A Grocery Item With a Resale Price, Not a Public Money
Around 2011 and 2012, police and retailers in several American cities reported organized theft of a well-known laundry detergent, and some accounts said bottles were resold for cash or exchanged in illicit trades [9]. The product was recognizable, relatively costly, and easy to move, which made it useful as a stolen good with a going price. Some stores responded by locking shelves. Colorful official quotations about finding more detergent than another contraband should be read as rhetoric, not as a measure of a true currency system. Dollars remained the public money. The bottle was a commodity in a narrow resale market [9].
The unexpected fact is that a brand-new grocery item can acquire, in a black market, some of the jobs of a medium of exchange [9]. This article will not name a method of theft or a place to fence goods, and it will not reproduce a trademarked bottle as if it were a coin. The careful fact is a documented wave of reporting, a documented resale use, and a hard limit: this was not a street currency for ordinary life. Portability and a known price are not enough to make a national money.
A detergent can have a second price in a back room and still not be, in any public sense, cash.
Related: Top 10 Tallest Buildings in the World
10. Work Certificates That Lost Value If They Sat Still
In 1932, in the Depression-struck Austrian town of Wörgl, Mayor Michael Unterguggenberger issued municipal work certificates, in values tied to the schilling, to pay for public work [10]. Local shops took them, and the town took them for taxes. To remain valid, a note needed a periodic stamp that cost a small share of its face, a demurrage idea associated with the monetary reformer Silvio Gesell, so that holding the paper was slightly expensive and spending it was the rational move. The certificates circulated, public work went forward, and the experiment drew wide attention, including from other towns. Higher authorities, including the Austrian National Bank, held that the issue invaded a legal monopoly on money, and the experiment was stopped in 1933 [10].
The unexpected fact is that a town can, for a short time, make a money whose main design feature is a reason not to keep it [10]. This article will not copy official schilling designs or treat the episode as a miracle cure. The careful fact is a documented municipal issue, a documented stamp feature, documented attention, and a documented legal end. Later admirers have sometimes inflated the results. The file is still a real, brief experiment.
A certificate can build a road and still be, once a central bank objects, only a local memory.
Conclusion
The ten media above include a commissary fish, a camp cigarette, a noodle packet, a ghetto scrip issued under coercion, a shop mark backed by tins, a tea brick, a voluntary town hour, a stamped Bavarian note, a stolen grocery item with a resale price, and a municipal Depression certificate. Each circulated in a real setting. Each had a wall, a peg, a shop, or a law around it.
An alternative currency is easiest to understand at its limit. The limit is not a footnote. It is the thing that kept the token from being ordinary national cash.
- ^ [1] Reporting and later studies of packaged mackerel as an informal commissary currency in some United States prisons after mid-2000s smoking bans, treated as a closed-wall medium and not as a market guide. The Wall Street Journal, reporting on prison mackerel Britannica: money
- ^ [2] R. A. Radford, "The Economic Organisation of a P.O.W. Camp," Economica (1945), and later economic discussions of cigarettes as a camp currency. Economica, Radford 1945 Britannica: money
- ^ [3] Sociological research by Michael Gibson-Light on instant-noodle packets as a medium of exchange in a studied state prison. Britannica: prison American Sociological Association, related reporting
- ^ [4] Historical accounts of Theresienstadt ghetto scrip, the ghetto bank, and the propagandistic and coercive setting, without reproduction of note designs or graphic description of suffering. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum Encyclopedia Britannica: Theresienstadt
- ^ [5] Radford's account of paper "bully marks" issued in a camp shop and of the later loss of confidence when food supplies failed. Economica, Radford 1945 Britannica: prisoner of war
- ^ [6] Histories of compressed-tea trade into Mongolia, Tibet, and Siberia, and of tea bricks used in some places as commodity money, including museum examples. British Museum collections Britannica: tea
- ^ [7] Accounts of Ithaca HOURS, Paul Glover, and voluntary local-currency practice in Ithaca, New York, beginning in 1991, with organizer-reported totals treated as such. https://www.britannica.com/topic/local-currency Ithaca HOURS historical materials
- ^ [8] Accounts of the Chiemgauer, Christian Gelleri, the euro peg, and the demurrage or stamp feature designed to keep the notes moving. Britannica: Bavaria Chiemgauer project information
- ^ [9] Contemporary reporting on theft and illicit resale of a well-known laundry detergent around 2011 and 2012, described as a commodity with a going price and not as a public currency or a theft guide. The New York Times and related reporting Britannica: black market
- ^ [10] Historical accounts of the 1932–1933 Wörgl work-certificate experiment, its Gesell-style stamp, and its end under national monetary authority, without official-note copies. Britannica: Great Depression Britannica: Austria
Discussion
Log in with