7 Views 0 Comments 0 Shares

Top 10 Art Competitions That Produced Well-Known Works

Listen to this article Free TTS Play using your browser's built-in text-to-speech

Spread Your Love for Finepedia

Featured image for Top 10 Art Competitions That Produced Well-Known Works

Some famous buildings, doors, and parks began as competition entries, but a winning design is not always the work as it was later built.

The ten cases below are the ancient anecdote of Zeuxis and Parrhasius, the 1401 Florence baptistery-door competition, Edgar Allan Poe's 1833 prize story, the Palace of Westminster reconstruction contest, the Central Park Greensward Plan, the 1922 Chicago Tribune Tower competition, the contest for Canberra, the Olympic art competitions, the Sydney Opera House contest, and the Vietnam Veterans Memorial competition. A popular story that tied "America the Beautiful" to a 1929 music-club contest does not match the better-supported file, in which a poem of the 1890s was later paired with an already written hymn tune, so it is not used here. This article will not reproduce famous compositions, facades, or memorial walls.

Key Facts

ContestWhat is documentedA limit
1Pliny's story of a painted curtain that fooled ZeuxisAn anecdote about illusion, not a formal event with a surviving jury record
2The 1401 Florence competition for a baptistery door, won by Lorenzo GhibertiIt is the Florence baptistery, not a "French" one; the trial panels should not be copied here
3Poe's "MS. Found in a Bottle" won an 1833 Baltimore newspaper contestA career help, not an instant escape from hardship
4Charles Barry won the Westminster reconstruction competition; A. W. N. Pugin was crucial to the Gothic detailThe fire of 1834 was the occasion; the surviving medieval fabric had to be kept
5Olmsted and Vaux's Greensward Plan won the 1858 Central Park competitionA great landscaped public park, not automatically the first green space in the country
6Howells and Hood won the 1922 Tribune Tower competitionFamous losing entries are part of the history, not only the built tower
7Walter Burley Griffin and Marion Mahony Griffin won the 1912 Federal Capital contestThe city as built changed many of the more specific ideas
8Olympic art competitions ran from 1912 to 1948Coubertin's own literary prize should be described carefully; a Yeats painting medal belongs to Jack B. Yeats in 1924
9Jorn Utzon won the 1957 Sydney Opera House competitionHe did not remain to finish the building as first imagined
10Maya Lin won the 1981 Vietnam Veterans Memorial competition as a young studentEarly controversy, later esteem, and a later added figurative group are all part of the file

1. A Contest That Lives in a Natural History

Pliny the Elder, in his Natural History, tells of a contest between the painters Zeuxis and Parrhasius, placed in the late fifth century before the Common Era [1]. In the story, Zeuxis paints grapes so convincing that birds approach them; Parrhasius paints a curtain so convincing that Zeuxis asks for it to be drawn aside. Zeuxis concedes, because he has fooled birds and his rival has fooled him. The tale is one of the most famous ancient remarks on illusion in art. It is not a documented "Olympiad art contest" with a surviving entry list, and it should be read as an anecdote with a moral, not as a modern jury's minutes [1].

The unexpected fact is how long a joke about a curtain has done the work of an art-historical event [1]. This article will not reconstruct the grapes or the curtain. The careful fact is a documented story in Pliny and a hard limit on what can be claimed as a historical competition. Illusion was the point. The prize is part of the parable.

A contest can be famous for centuries and still be, as evidence, a story about looking.

2. Florence, 1401: A Door, a Guild, and Two Trial Panels

In 1401 the Arte di Calimala, the cloth merchants' guild of Florence, held a competition for a new bronze door of the city's baptistery, the Baptistery of Saint John [2]. Several artists entered; the two who dominate later memory are the young Lorenzo Ghiberti and Filippo Brunelleschi. Each had to make a trial panel of the Sacrifice of Isaac, inside a set Gothic frame and under limits of size and material. Ghiberti won and spent many years on the north door. Both trial panels survive, which is why the contest can still be discussed as a comparison. Later writing sometimes moves the baptistery to France or converts a long fee into a modern headline salary; those flourishes are not needed [2].

The unexpected fact is that a jury exercise became, for later historians, a convenient birth scene of a new century's sculpture [2]. This article will not reproduce the trial compositions. The careful fact is a documented Florentine guild contest, a documented winner, and a documented long execution. Brunelleschi lost the door and later won a dome. The contest was not the whole of either career.

A quatrefoil can be a rule for a competition and still not be, in this article, a picture to copy.

3. A Newspaper Prize That Helped a Writer Be Seen

In 1833 the Baltimore Saturday Visiter offered a prize for a tale, and Edgar Allan Poe's "MS. Found in a Bottle" won it [3]. The award, and the attention around it, helped him find editorial work and a public as a writer of short fiction. It did not, by itself, end his money troubles, and it should not be told as if a single envelope created a posthumous reputation. The earlier family history, including a strained life with his foster father John Allan, is context for why the prize mattered. The contest itself is the documented fact that belongs on this list [3].

The unexpected fact is that a local paper's prize can still be, in a career file, a real hinge [3]. This article will not quote the story. The careful fact is a documented 1833 win and a documented later career that remained financially hard. A contest can launch a name. It cannot, in this case, be asked to do more than that.

A prize is not a fortune. It can still be the first time a jury says the work is public.

Sponsored

4. A Burned Palace, a Gothic Brief, and a Shared Credit

After the 1834 fire at the Palace of Westminster, a competition was held for a new Houses of Parliament, to be designed in a Gothic or Elizabethan manner and to keep important surviving medieval fabric, including Westminster Hall [4]. Charles Barry's entry won. Augustus Welby Northmore Pugin, whose Gothic detail and interiors are now seen as central to the building's character, worked with Barry in a collaboration that later generations have had to describe more fairly than some Victorian accounts did. The palace as built is therefore a winning design, a partnership, and a negotiation with what the fire had left [4].

The unexpected fact is that a reconstruction contest can be, at the same time, a conservation project [4]. This article will not copy the river front or the towers. The careful fact is a documented competition, a documented official winner, and a documented second author of the Gothic language. Barry organized the palace. Pugin gave it much of its dress.

A winner's name on a plaque can hide a partner who designed the very ornaments people remember.

5. Greensward: A Park Plan That Won a Jury, Then a City

In 1857 and 1858 New York held a competition for the design of Central Park [5]. The winning Greensward Plan was the joint work of Frederick Law Olmsted, then the park's superintendent, and Calvert Vaux, who urged the entry. Their plan imagined a pastoral public ground in the heart of a growing city, with circulation separated so that a carriage, a walker, and a later transverse road would not all occupy the same scene. Central Park is often called the first great landscaped public park in the United States. Earlier squares, gardens, and rural cemeteries complicate any claim that it was the first green space as such [5].

The unexpected fact is that a park now treated as inevitable was, in origin, a judged set of drawings [5]. This article will not copy the plan as a map. The careful fact is a documented contest, documented co-authors, and a later park that was also a political and construction project, not only a pastoral dream. Vaux brought a design partner's eye. Olmsted brought, among other things, the site itself.

A lawn can look natural and still have been, first, a competition sheet.

6. A Newspaper Tower, and a Contest Famous for Its Losers Too

In 1922 the Chicago Tribune held an international competition for a new headquarters tower [6]. The winners, John Mead Howells and Raymond Hood, designed a Gothic skyscraper that was then built on Michigan Avenue. The contest is equally famous, among architects, for the unbuilt entries: a range of modern and eccentric proposals that circulated in publication and influenced later argument about what a tall office building could be. A competition can therefore produce a well-known work and, at the same time, a well-known set of alternatives [6].

The unexpected fact is that a losing drawing can have a longer theoretical life than a built cornice [6]. This article will not copy the tower's crown or the famous rejected schemes. The careful fact is a documented jury choice, a documented built result, and a documented afterlife of the runners-up. The newspaper wanted a landmark. It also, unintentionally, staged a debate.

A prize can go to one address and still leave the century arguing about the drawings that did not win.

7. Canberra's Plan, and a City That Revised Its Winners

In 1912 Walter Burley Griffin and Marion Mahony Griffin won the international competition to design Canberra, the new Australian federal capital [7]. Marion Mahony Griffin's perspectival drawings, already admired from her earlier work in a Chicago studio associated with Frank Lloyd Wright, were essential to how the entry was seen. The couple moved to Australia to carry the plan forward. Politics, official changes, and later planners altered many specific ideas, even as a large geometric and landscape logic of the winning scheme remained visible. A capital can be a contest's child and still not be the contest's facsimile [7].

The unexpected fact is that a rendering, as much as a diagram, can win a city [7]. This article will not copy the plan or claim that one partner's earlier studio work invented another architect's fame by itself. The careful fact is a documented 1912 win, a documented shared authorship, and a documented later divergence. They designed a capital. The capital, as usual, talked back.

A prize-winning city is still, after the first decade, a negotiation.

8. Medals for Art, Beside the Track, for a Few Games Only

Pierre de Coubertin wanted the modern Games to include juried art as well as sport, and from 1912 in Stockholm through 1948 there were official Olympic art competitions in fields such as architecture, literature, music, painting, and sculpture, usually on a sporting theme [8]. The literature gold in 1912 went to a work signed with a pseudonym, "Ode to Sport," later revealed to be Coubertin's own; the episode is documented and still slightly awkward. Later juries were more formal. Among painting medals, Jack B. Yeats, the Irish painter and brother of the poet W. B. Yeats, won a silver in 1924 for a picture of a Dublin swim, a fact sometimes garbled in later retellings. The art medals were later dropped [8].

The unexpected fact is that a gold medal could once be awarded for a poem or a canvas at the same Games as a sprint [8]. This article will not reproduce those pictures, and it will not display official emblems. The careful fact is a documented 1912–1948 institution, a documented founder's prize, and a documented later end. Sport was the theme. Art was, for a time, a formal event.

A contest can be official and still look, in hindsight, like a strange guest on the program.

9. A Winning Shell, and an Architect Who Did Not Stay to the Opening

In 1957 a Danish architect, Jorn Utzon, won an international competition for a national opera house on Bennelong Point in Sydney, an entry that a juror, often identified as Eero Saarinen, is said to have rescued from a discarded pile [9]. The scheme became one of the best-known buildings of the century. It was also, in construction, a long ordeal of technical difficulty, rising cost, and political conflict. Utzon resigned in 1966; the house opened in 1973 under other hands, with interiors that were not his first plan. Early public mockery of the form is part of the reception history [9].

The unexpected fact is that a competition win can be both a world-famous success and a personal rupture [9]. This article will not copy the roof's silhouette. The careful fact is a documented 1957 prize, a documented later resignation, and a documented opening without the winner in charge. The concept was his. The finished rooms were a compromise.

A landmark can bear a winner's name and still not be, in every interior, the winner's building.

10. A Student Entry, a Wall of Names, and a Public Argument

In 1981 Maya Lin, then a Yale undergraduate, won an open national competition for the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington [10]. The design, a cut in the ground and a dark wall to carry names, was at first fiercely contested, then, for many visitors, deeply accepted. A later figurative sculpture was added as a compromise with some critics. Lin's youth and the apparent simplicity of the scheme were part of the early argument; they were not, by themselves, a lack of seriousness. The memorial's later standing is now one of the strongest cases for what a competition can put on federal ground [10].

The unexpected fact is that a student board can become, after a public fight, a central American memorial [10]. This article will not reconstruct the wall or treat the controversy as a score to settle. The careful fact is a documented open contest, a documented early resistance, a documented later regard, and a documented added element. The names were the point. The argument was about how a war should be seen.

A competition can ask for a monument and then discover that the hardest work is the public's first look.

Conclusion

The ten cases above include an ancient anecdote, a Florentine door, a newspaper tale, a rebuilt parliament, a city park, a newspaper tower, a federal capital, a short-lived Olympic art jury, an opera house finished without its winner, and a memorial that had to survive its first reception. Contests produce works. They also produce revisions, partners, losers, and arguments.

A jury can choose a design. Time, money, and later hands still decide what the public finally walks through.

What surprised you most? Tell us in the comments.

Discussion 0

0 / 5000
Comment as a guest

Questions or grievances: Dhiraj Sharma, Grievance Officer — [email protected].

Log in with
  • No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion.