Some islands remembered as deserted have documented episodes of marooning, science, or, in one case, a living community that is not a vacancy at all.
The ten places below are the poorly identified Isle of Demons, Robinson Crusoe Island in the Juan Fernandez group, Roatan in the period of Philip Ashton's survival, Elephant Island during Shackleton's expedition, Palmyra Atoll, the Flannan Isles, Clipperton Island, Tromelin Island, Queimada Grande, and North Sentinel Island. This article is a settlement, wreck, and scientific history. It is not a collection of ghost stories, and it is not a landing guide.
Key Facts
| Island | What is documented | A limit on the usual story |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | A 1542 marooning told in early French accounts, on an island whose exact site is still argued | Later "demon" color is not the primary source |
| 2 | Alexander Selkirk's stay on Mas a Tierra, 1704-1709 | The island is inhabited today and has another name |
| 3 | Philip Ashton's published 1720s survival on Roatan after escaping a pirate crew | Roatan is now a populated tourist island, not a vacancy |
| 4 | The 1916 wait on Elephant Island after the loss of Endurance | Endurance was crushed in the Weddell Sea, not on this beach |
| 5 | Palmyra as a wildlife refuge, with a documented 1974 criminal case | A crime is not a curse |
| 6 | The 1900 disappearance of three Flannan Isles keepers | Popular props such as a stopped clock and a half-eaten meal are later embellishment |
| 7 | The Mexican garrison and 1917 rescue on Clipperton | The violence can be named without being restaged |
| 8 | Tromelin Island, where Malagasy survivors of a 1761 wreck waited for rescue | This item replaces a poorly evidenced "ghost island" tied to a missing sailor |
| 9 | Queimada Grande, habitat of the golden lancehead, with landing tightly restricted | Density slogans and lurid venom talk are not a scientific summary, and this is not a dare |
| 10 | North Sentinel Island, home to the Sentinelese, a living people who refuse lasting contact | The island is not deserted, and this is not a contact guide |
1. A Marooning Whose Island Is Still Debated
In 1542, during a French expedition led by Jean-Francois de La Rocque de Roberval, Marguerite de La Rocque, a noblewoman and Roberval's relative, was put ashore in the region of the Strait of Belle Isle with a male companion and a servant [1]. Early accounts, especially those associated with Andre Thevet, describe a long marooning, the deaths of her companions and of an infant, and her later rescue. Mapmakers of the period marked an "Isle of Demons" in those waters. The exact landing place has never been settled, and later writers added supernatural color that the first reports do not require [1].
The unexpected fact is how firmly a famous island can exist in a story and still be, on a modern chart, a debate [1]. This article will not linger on the private relationship that preceded the punishment, and it will not treat the dead as a horror scene. The careful fact is a documented sixteenth-century marooning, an uncertain geography, and a woman who survived a northern winter long enough to be taken off. Cartographic demons are a later overlay. The human record is enough.
An island can be famous under a name no surveyor would now use. The name is part of the history. The rocks still have to be identified.
2. A Volunteer Castaway on an Island That Kept Its Later Name
Alexander Selkirk, a Scottish sailor, was put ashore in 1704 on Mas a Tierra, in Chile's Juan Fernandez Islands, after a dispute with his captain about the condition of the ship Cinque Ports [2]. He had asked to be left rather than continue on a vessel he thought unsound. He remained until 1709, when Woodes Rogers's expedition took him off. The episode was widely published and later fed, among other sources, into Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe. The island was renamed Robinson Crusoe Island in the twentieth century and has a settled village. It is not deserted now [2].
The unexpected fact is that the most famous "deserted island" stay in English letters began as a sailor's own hard choice, not as a wreck [2]. This article will not treat Selkirk as a fictional character, and it will not pretend the modern island is empty. The careful fact is a dated four-year sojourn, a documented rescue, and a later literary afterlife that should not be confused with the ship's log. The Cinque Ports did, in fact, run into serious trouble later. Selkirk's suspicion was not only temperament.
A novel can rename an island. The stay that inspired the novel is still a matter of maritime record.
3. A Massachusetts Fisherman's Months on Roatan
Philip Ashton, a fisherman from Massachusetts, was taken by the pirate Edward Low in 1722 and, after months of captivity, escaped onto Roatan, off the Honduras coast [3]. His later published narrative describes about sixteen months of solitary survival before he was picked up. The account is a primary source for that episode, with the usual caution that a captivity narrative can also be a shaped book. The Roatan of today is a populated tourist island. Ashton's Roatan was a place he could hide and live off the land [3].
Related: Top 10 Largest Islands in the World
The unexpected fact is how completely a survival story can attach to an island that later became ordinary and busy [3]. This article will not retell pirate violence as entertainment, and it will not treat the modern island as a wilderness park. The careful fact is a documented 1720s sojourn, a named captor, and a book that made the stay famous. "Deserted," here, is a historical condition, not a permanent label.
A beach can be a hideout in one century and a pier in another. Both facts can be true of the same shoreline.
4. A Barren Camp That Waited for a Small Boat
Elephant Island, off the Antarctic Peninsula, is the ice-bound shore where twenty-two men of Ernest Shackleton's Endurance expedition camped in 1916 after months on drifting ice [4]. Their ship had been crushed in the Weddell Sea, not at this island. Shackleton and five companions then left in the boat James Caird for South Georgia to seek help. The men at Point Wild waited through the southern winter until a Chilean navy steamer, the Yelcho, under Luis Pardo, took them off. All of the expedition's men survived the wreck and the wait [4].
The unexpected fact is how much of the famous story happens after the ship is already gone, on a beach that offered water and penguins but little else [4]. This article will not turn cold and hunger into a spectacle, and it will not move the wreck to the wrong sea. The careful fact is a dated 1916 encampment, a boat journey, and a documented rescue. Endurance itself, later found on the Weddell Sea floor, is a different chapter. Elephant Island is the waiting room.
A rock can be uninhabitable and still be, for a season, the whole of a community. In 1916 that community kept a watch for a sail.
5. A Refuge, and a Crime That Is Not a Haunting
Palmyra Atoll, a remote American territory in the Line Islands, is managed as a wildlife refuge, with a small rotating presence of researchers and managers, not a resident town [5]. It has a wartime airfield history and a later conservation life under the United States Fish and Wildlife Service and The Nature Conservancy. In 1974, a criminal case that began with the yacht Sea Wind left two visitors, Malcolm and Eleanor Graham, dead; a later trial established a murder and related crimes. That case is a documented legal history. It is not a curse, and it does not require a list of "unexplainable phenomena" [5].
The unexpected fact is how quickly a lonely atoll acquires a haunted reputation once a real crime has been told often enough as a campfire story [5]. This article will not restage the killings, and it will not treat the refuge as a cursed set. The careful fact is a managed conservation site, a wartime layer, and one notorious criminal file. Science and bird life are the ordinary present tense. The crime is a closed chapter of human law, not a weather pattern.
Related: Top 10 Artificial Islands Built by Human Hands
An atoll can be remote without being supernatural. Palmyra's documented history is already strange enough when it is told straight.
6. Three Keepers, and a Story That Grew Props
In December 1900, the three lighthouse keepers on Eilean Mor, in Scotland's Flannan Isles, Thomas Marshall, James Ducat, and Donald MacArthur, disappeared [6]. A relief vessel found the light unattended and the men gone. The later official inquiry pointed toward heavy weather and a wave or swell at the landing, while the men were dealing with equipment, as the most sober explanation. Popular retellings added a half-eaten meal, an overturned chair, and a clock that had stopped. Those theatrical details are not a reliable inventory of what the relief party recorded [6].
The unexpected fact is that the disappearance is stark enough without the furniture of a ghost story [6]. This article will not invent a supernatural cause, and it will not treat the keepers as characters in a campfire tale. The careful fact is a dated absence of three named men, a working light, and a weather-and-landing hypothesis that remains the leading official reading. The northern Atlantic does not need a curse to be lethal at a west landing.
A mystery can be a missing crew and a rough sea. Adding a stopped clock does not make the file more true.
7. A Garrison Cut Off, and a Rescue in 1917
Clipperton Island, a low French atoll in the eastern Pacific, held a small Mexican garrison and families in the 1910s, left there in connection with guano working and a claim of occupation [7]. The Mexican Revolution interrupted supply. Many of the men died of scurvy and related hardship. The remaining lighthouse keeper, Victoriano Alvarez, then terrorized the surviving women and children until they killed him, shortly before an American ship, the Yorktown, took the survivors off in 1917. The episode is documented and grim. It does not need a novelist's scene-by-scene restaging [7].
The unexpected fact is that a nearly featureless atoll can still have a political history: a Mexican detachment on a French speck, stranded by a revolution at home [7]. This article will not describe the assaults, and it will not treat the survivors as figures in a sensational plot. The careful fact is a cut-off garrison, a 1917 rescue, and a later French administration of an uninhabited nature reserve. The "king of Clipperton" headline is a real man's brief, brutal power. It should be named and then left in the record.
Related: Top 10 Phantom Islands That Never Existed
A rescue can arrive after the worst has already happened. The Yorktown's arrival is the end of the occupation story, not a softening of it.
8. Tromelin, Where Survivors Waited Fifteen Years
Tromelin Island, a small, isolated French island in the western Indian Ocean, is the documented site of a long marooning after the 1761 wreck of the French ship L'Utile [8]. The ship had been carrying Malagasy people who had been enslaved. After the wreck, the French crew built a departure vessel and left, promising a return that did not come for many years. A group of Malagasy survivors remained. In 1776, a French expedition under the Chevalier de Tromelin, for whom the island is named, rescued the last survivors, commonly counted as seven women and an infant. The island later held a meteorological station and remains a nature reserve, without a civilian town [8].
The unexpected fact is how completely a "deserted island" story can be a story about people who were abandoned, not about a haunting [8]. This article uses Tromelin in place of a poorly evidenced "ghost island" sometimes attached to a missing twenty-first-century sailor, which is not a documented island history in the same sense. The careful fact is a dated wreck, a long wait, a named rescue, and later archaeological work that has supported the survivor camp as a real place. The weather station is a modern footnote. The camp is the history.
An island can be almost empty and still be, for fifteen years, a community that was not supposed to be forgotten. Tromelin is that community's name now.
9. A Restricted Island, and a Viper That Is Not a Horror Film
Ilha da Queimada Grande, off the coast of Sao Paulo state in Brazil, is the range of the golden lancehead, Bothrops insularis, a critically endangered pit viper found there and not in a wild state on the adjacent mainland [9]. Landing is tightly restricted by Brazilian authorities, with access generally limited to authorized research. Popular figures of "one to five snakes per square meter" are repeated far more often than they are carefully measured, and they should be treated as a slogan, not as a census. The venom is medically serious. It does not need language about melting flesh, and alleged lighthouse-keeper deaths in the early twentieth century are often told without a solid public file [9].
The unexpected fact is that the island's real scientific interest is an isolated, threatened snake population, not a dare [9]. This article will not offer a landing tip, and it will not treat the viper as a monster. The careful fact is a documented endemic species, a legal restriction with both safety and conservation reasons, and a literature that is more cautious than television. An empty lighthouse, when it is mentioned at all, is a management fact. It is not a campfire ending.
Related: Top 10 Phantom Islands That Fooled Mapmakers
A closed island can be a laboratory without being a dungeon. Queimada Grande is closed because the animals, and the visitors, are better off that way.
10. An Inhabited Island, Not a Vacancy
North Sentinel Island, in the Andaman Islands, is the home of the Sentinelese, a living Indigenous people who have consistently refused lasting contact with outsiders [10]. The island is therefore the opposite of deserted. Indian law and a protective buffer zone prohibit approach. Brief, often harmful, official contact efforts in the later twentieth century were later replaced by a policy of non-interference. In 2006, two fishermen who went inshore were killed; in 2018, an American, John Allen Chau, made an illegal approach and was killed. Those events are facts of a protected boundary. They are not an invitation, a martyr tale, or a measure of a people as "primitive" [10].
The unexpected fact, on a list of deserted islands, is that this famous "empty" place is inhabited, and that the vacancy is only in the outsider's wish to land [10]. This article will not describe a way to approach the island, and it will not use outdated labels that freeze a living community in a stone-age cartoon. The careful fact is a documented no-contact policy, a legal exclusion zone, and a people entitled to remain unbothered. Outsider curiosity is not a right of entry.
An island can be closed because someone already lives there. North Sentinel is that kind of closure, and it should be left in place.
Conclusion
The ten islands above include a debated sixteenth-century marooning, a Selkirk sojourn on an island that is now a village, a 1720s survival story on a now-busy Roatan, a 1916 Antarctic camp, a Pacific refuge wrongly called cursed, a Scottish lighthouse disappearance stripped of later props, a grim Clipperton occupation, a fifteen-year wait on Tromelin, a restricted Brazilian viper island, and North Sentinel, which is not deserted at all. Several popular versions of these places are ghost stories. The record is not.
A documented island history should say who was there, who was left, and who is there now. It should also know when to stay offshore.
- ^ [1] Early modern and later historical accounts of Marguerite de La Rocque's 1542 marooning, including the uncertain identification of the so-called Isle of Demons. Britannica: Newfoundland and Labrador Wikipedia: Marguerite de La Rocque
- ^ [2] Maritime and island histories of Alexander Selkirk's 1704-1709 stay on Mas a Tierra, now Robinson Crusoe Island, including the later literary afterlife and the island's present settlement. Britannica: Alexander Selkirk Britannica: Juan Fernandez Islands
- ^ [3] The published early-eighteenth-century narrative of Philip Ashton's escape from Edward Low and survival on Roatan, read as a period source about a then-sparsely used island. Britannica: Roatan Wikipedia: Philip Ashton
- ^ [4] Expedition histories of the 1916 Elephant Island encampment, the James Caird voyage, and the rescue by the Yelcho, with the loss of Endurance correctly placed in the Weddell Sea. Britannica: Ernest Shackleton Britannica: Elephant Island
- ^ [5] Official and historical accounts of Palmyra Atoll as a wildlife refuge, and of the documented 1974 Sea Wind criminal case, without curse framing or a restaging of the crimes. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service: Palmyra Atoll Britannica: Line Islands
- ^ [6] Official and careful historical accounts of the December 1900 disappearance of the Flannan Isles keepers, distinguishing the inquiry's weather-and-landing reading from later folkloric props. Britannica: Outer Hebrides Wikipedia: Flannan Isles Lighthouse
- ^ [7] Historical accounts of the Mexican garrison on Clipperton Island, the interruption of supply during the Revolution, and the 1917 rescue, without graphic restaging of the violence. Britannica: Clipperton Island Wikipedia: Clipperton Island
- ^ [8] Historical and archaeological accounts of the 1761 wreck of L'Utile, the Malagasy survivors on Tromelin Island, and the 1776 rescue, used here as a documented island history in place of an uncharted "ghost island." Britannica: Scattered Islands Wikipedia: Tromelin Island
- ^ [9] Biological and official accounts of Ilha da Queimada Grande and of Bothrops insularis, including landing restrictions, with popular density slogans and lurid venom language treated as unsound. ICMBio Britannica: Bothrops
- ^ [10] Legal and anthropological accounts of North Sentinel Island and the Sentinelese, including India's non-interference policy and the prohibition on approach, without contact instructions or primitivist labels. Britannica: North Sentinel Island Andaman and Nicobar Administration
Discussion
Log in with