Some famous paintings have been attacked in public, and the better history is the incident, the motive, and the repair, not a restaging of the damage.
The ten cases below are a Monet in Dublin, a Rothko at Tate Modern, repeated attempts on the Mona Lisa, a decades-long series of museum attacks in Europe, the Rokeby Venus, a Duchamp replica, a Cy Twombly canvas in Avignon, Picasso's Guernica at the Museum of Modern Art, a Barnett Newman in Amsterdam, and a Repin at the Tretyakov Gallery. This is a history of documented public attacks and later conservation. It is not a guide, it will not describe a method or a vulnerability as a lesson, and it will not restage damage on a famous composition. Motives range from protest and grievance to illness and self-advertisement. "Pettiness" is too small a word for several of these files.
Key Facts
| Work and incident | What is documented | A limit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Andrew Shannon punched a Monet at the National Gallery of Ireland in 2012 | CCTV and a later conviction undercut a "dizzy spell" story; the canvas was later restored |
| 2 | In 2012 a man wrote on Rothko's Black on Maroon at Tate Modern | He called it an art movement; the museum and the courts treated it as criminal damage |
| 3 | The Mona Lisa has been targeted more than once; a 2009 thrown cup hit the glass | Earlier mid-century incidents did slight damage before later glazing; recent attacks have usually stopped at the glass |
| 4 | Hans-Joachim Bohlmann attacked dozens of works in European museums over many years | Mental illness is part of the record; this is not a catalogue of tools |
| 5 | Mary Richardson slashed the Rokeby Venus in 1914 after Emmeline Pankhurst's arrest | A suffrage protest, later mixed with remarks about viewers, not a random tantrum |
| 6 | Pierre Pinoncelli twice attacked authorized Fountain replicas, in 1993 and 2006 | The 1917 original was already lost; a "Dada tribute" did not cancel the damage |
| 7 | In 2007 Rindy Sam left a lipstick mark on a pale Twombly canvas in Avignon | She called it an act of love; the stain was still a conservation problem |
| 8 | Tony Shafrazi sprayed words on Guernica at MoMA in 1974 | The paint came off a varnished surface; notoriety later and a protest claim both belong in the file |
| 9 | Gerard Jan van Bladeren cut a Newman in Amsterdam in 1986 and later attacked another | The restoration itself became a public fight |
| 10 | In 2018 Igor Podporin broke the glass on Repin's Ivan picture at the Tretyakov and tore the canvas | He first blamed drink, then a grievance about the subject; the painting had been attacked before |
1. A Monet in Dublin, a Punch, and a Long Repair
In June 2012 a visitor, Andrew Shannon, made a hole in Claude Monet's Argenteuil Basin with a Single Sailboat at the National Gallery of Ireland [1]. The 1874 canvas had to be taken off view for a long conservation campaign, often described as lasting about eighteen months, before it returned. In public comments Shannon sometimes spoke of protest and later of a dizzy fall. Reporting on the trial, and on gallery footage, treated the blow as deliberate. He was convicted and sentenced to prison. This article will not describe the tear, the blow, or the landscape as a picture to be copied [1].
The unexpected fact is how quickly a gallery room can become a crime scene over a single gesture [1]. The careful fact is a documented attack, a documented conviction, and a documented return after painstaking repair. A restoration can hide a wound from ordinary viewing and still not make the canvas new. The museum's job after the fact was conservation, not a debate about whether the painting had "asked for" a reaction.
A famous landscape can be fragile in a way a photograph of still water never suggests. The file is about that fragility, and about a later, slow mending.
2. A Marker on a Rothko, and a Claim That It Was Art
In October 2012 Wlodzimierz Umaniec, also known as Vladimir Umanets, wrote on Mark Rothko's Black on Maroon at Tate Modern in London [2]. He belonged to a self-named "Yellowism" project and said he had added value, or made a new work, by putting a signature and a slogan on the painting. The museum, and then the courts, treated the act as criminal damage. Because Rothko's surfaces can be absorbent and unvarnished, the ink posed a hard conservation problem. The painting was off view for many months, at high cost, before it returned. Umaniec received a prison sentence and later expressed some regret [2].
The unexpected fact is that an attacker can sincerely use the language of art history while still being, in law, a person who damaged a work [2]. This article will not quote the graffiti as a display, will not reconstruct the canvas, and will not discuss solvents as a method. The careful fact is a documented 2012 incident, a documented two-year-scale repair, and a documented sentence. Intention as "addition" did not change the damage.
A quiet room designed for looking can be undone by a few words in the corner. The repair, not the slogan, is what the public later got back.
3. The Mona Lisa, More Often Hit on the Glass Than on the Paint
Leonardo da Vinci's Mona Lisa, at the Louvre, has been a target in part because it is so famous [3]. In August 2009 a woman threw a ceramic cup, bought in the museum shop, at the portrait. It broke on the protective glass; the painting was unharmed. Reporting linked the act to anger after a French residency or citizenship refusal. The picture has a longer attack file: in 1956 it was damaged by a stone, and, in another incident that year, by acid, before later glazing made direct contact much harder. More recent gestures, including later food thrown at the glass, have mostly been spectacles that stopped at the barrier [3].
Related: Top 10 Art Restorations That Went Badly Wrong
The unexpected fact is that the world's most watched painting can be, in several modern incidents, a story about glass [3]. This article will not copy the portrait or treat a barrier as a puzzle. The careful fact is a documented 2009 throw, documented earlier mid-century damage, and a later pattern of attacks that fail to reach the paint. Fame attracts a scene. The glazing is why many of those scenes end in a mess on the floor.
A work can be repeatedly attacked and still, after a certain date, survive because the public now looks at it through a shield.
4. A Long Series of Attacks, Not a Single Shock
From the late 1970s into the early 2000s, Hans-Joachim Bohlmann attacked many paintings in European museums, among them works associated with Albrecht Dürer and other well-known names [4]. The damage, often chemical, left some canvases permanently marked even after conservation. Museums changed how they watched rooms partly because of that long campaign. Psychiatric illness is part of the public record and should not be flattened into a story about a man who merely found museums "trite." This article will not list a method, a recipe, or a set of unprotected targets [4].
The unexpected fact is that a "serial" file can be as important to museum history as a single famous slash [4]. The careful fact is a documented series, documented harm to multiple works, and a documented later tightening of gallery practice. The numbers sometimes attached to the case, including headline insurance figures, should be read as estimates, not as a scoreboard. Illness and injury both belong in the sentence.
A career of attacks is still a history of damage. It is not a catalogue to be studied for technique.
5. The Rokeby Venus, Slashed in a Suffrage Protest
On 10 March 1914, Mary Richardson attacked Diego Velázquez's Rokeby Venus in the National Gallery in London, slashing the canvas [5]. She said she was answering the arrest of the suffrage leader Emmeline Pankhurst, and she later also spoke about the way some men looked at the nude figure. The protest was political, and it was aimed at a famous picture of a woman's body. The painting was repaired and returned; traces of the cuts can still be discussed by conservators. Richardson's later political life, including a period of association with the British Union of Fascists, complicates any simple martyr reading, but it does not erase the 1914 motive [5].
The unexpected fact is that a "vandalism" file can also be a document of a political campaign [5]. This article will not describe the figure, the cuts, or the tool as a scene to restage. The careful fact is a documented date, a documented suffrage context, and a documented restoration. Calling the act mere pettiness misses the politics. Calling it only a triumph misses the damaged work and the later biography.
Related: Top 10 Most Popular Artists of All Time
A museum picture can be chosen because it is famous, and also because of what it shows. Both reasons are in the 1914 record.
6. A Lost Original, Authorized Copies, and Two Later Attacks
Marcel Duchamp's Fountain, a urinal submitted in 1917, does not survive as the first object; museums show later authorized replicas [6]. In 1993, at an exhibition in Nîmes, the performance artist Pierre Pinoncelli used one replica as a fixture and also struck it. In 2006, at the Centre Pompidou in Paris, he struck another replica and chipped it. He presented the acts as a Dada tribute, a way of refusing the work's later museum dignity. Courts and the institutions fined him and treated the chipping as damage to a valued object. A claim about "spirit" did not put the porcelain back as it had been [6].
The unexpected fact is that an object invented as a slight to institutions can still be, decades later, an institution's responsibility to protect [6]. This article will not offer a method or a crude restaging. The careful fact is a documented lost original, documented later copies, and two documented attacks on those copies. Replica status makes the legal and philosophical argument messier. It does not make the chip imaginary.
A joke that became a canonical work can still be harmed. The harm, in 2006, was a fact about a particular object on a particular floor.
7. A Lipstick Mark on a Pale Twombly, Called Love
In 2007, at the Collection Lambert in Avignon, Rindy Sam kissed a large pale canvas by Cy Twombly, leaving a lipstick mark [7]. Press accounts often identify the work as Phaedrus, a several-panel piece whose pale surface is part of its effect. Sam said she had been overcome and had committed an act of love. The museum and the owner treated it as damage. Conservators found the stain difficult to lift from a vulnerable surface, and the case went to court. Emotion, in that argument, was not a defense that erased the mark [7].
The unexpected fact is that a "soft" gesture can still be a conservation emergency [7]. This article will not reconstruct the panels or discuss cleaning as a recipe. The careful fact is a documented 2007 incident, a documented legal case, and a documented hard repair. A white field looks empty only to a person who thinks emptiness is an invitation. The work's integrity was the point of the complaint.
Related: Top 10 Most Famous Paintings in the World
A kiss can be intended as praise and still be, on an unvarnished surface, a stain that costs months to address.
8. Words Sprayed on Guernica, Then Wiped Away
On 28 February 1974, Tony Shafrazi sprayed paint on Pablo Picasso's Guernica at the Museum of Modern Art in New York [8]. Contemporary accounts give the words as "KILL LIES ALL," a phrase sometimes later misremembered in reverse. Shafrazi said he was protesting, in a moment tied to the Vietnam War and to the case of a lieutenant from the My Lai massacre. Because the surface was heavily varnished, the paint could be removed relatively quickly. The scandal remained. Shafrazi later became a well-known art dealer, a sequel that should be recorded as a fact of his career, not as a lesson that vandalism works [8].
The unexpected fact is that one of the century's most cited anti-war pictures could be used, briefly, as a billboard [8]. This article will not reconstruct the mural, quote the words as a graphic, or restage the war scene it depicts. The careful fact is a documented date, a documented protest claim, a documented quick cleaning, and a documented later professional life. Motive and ambition can sit in the same act. The painting, once cleaned, went back to being itself.
A varnish can save a surface and still not save a museum from an international incident.
9. A Cut Newman, and Then a Fight About the Repair
In 1986 Gerard Jan van Bladeren attacked Barnett Newman's Who's Afraid of Red, Yellow and Blue III at the Stedelijk Museum in Amsterdam, cutting the canvas [9]. He spoke of contempt for abstract painting and of doing what he claimed others wanted done. He later, after serving a sentence, attacked another Newman in the same museum. The 1986 work's restoration, associated with the conservator Daniel Goldreyer, became a public controversy, including allegations about how the large red field was put back, and a long legal quarrel. The incident is therefore two histories: the attack, and the argument about whether the repair respected the painting [9].
The unexpected fact is that a restoration can inherit the scandal of the damage [9]. This article will not reconstruct the field, describe a cutting method, or treat the later conservation debate as a workshop brief. The careful fact is a documented 1986 attack, a documented later second attack, and a documented fight over the repair. Dislike of a style is not a right to destroy it. Dislike of a restoration is a separate, and real, museum problem.
Related: Top 10 Most Expensive Paintings Ever Sold
A monochrome can look, to a hostile viewer, like nothing. To a conservator, after a cut, it is one of the hardest somethings to put back.
10. A Repin in Moscow, a Broken Barrier, and a Changing Story
In May 2018 Igor Podporin attacked Ilya Repin's 1885 painting of Ivan the Terrible and his injured son, at the Tretyakov Gallery in Moscow, breaking the protective glass with a stanchion and tearing the canvas in several places [10]. He first said he had been drinking and was overwhelmed by the picture. In later remarks he spoke of offense at the historical scene and of not believing the episode it shows. The canvas had been attacked before, in 1913. A major restoration followed the 2018 tears. This article will not restage the violent subject, copy the composition, or treat drink as a complete explanation [10].
The unexpected fact is that a viewer's quarrel with a historical story can be aimed at the painting that tells it [10]. The careful fact is a documented 2018 attack, a documented earlier one, a documented change in the attacker's account, and a documented later repair. Whether the historical episode itself is debated is a separate scholarly question. It does not authorize tearing the work.
A historic canvas can be injured because of what it depicts, and still need, afterward, only a conservator's patience.
Conclusion
The ten files above include a punched Monet, a marked Rothko, a repeatedly targeted Leonardo, a long European series of attacks, a suffrage slash, two assaults on Fountain replicas, a lipstick stain, sprayed words on Guernica, a cut Newman whose repair became a case, and a torn Repin. Some of the motives were political. Some were personal, clinical, or self-advertising. None of them is usefully studied as a method.
A public attack on a work of art has a date, a room, a motive, and usually a later conservation report. That is the history worth keeping. The damage itself does not need to be shown again.
- ^ [1] Reporting on the 2012 attack on Monet's Argenteuil Basin with a Single Sailboat at the National Gallery of Ireland, on the subsequent trial, and on the later conservation and return of the canvas, without a description of the tear as a method or a reconstruction of the picture. National Gallery of Ireland Britannica: Claude Monet
- ^ [2] Reporting on the 2012 writing on Mark Rothko's Black on Maroon at Tate Modern, on the "Yellowism" claim, and on the long conservation campaign and court sentence, without reconstruction of the painting. Tate Britannica: Mark Rothko
- ^ [3] Accounts of attacks on the Mona Lisa, including the 2009 thrown cup at the Louvre glass and earlier mid-1950s incidents that slightly damaged the paint before later protective glazing. Musée du Louvre Britannica: Mona Lisa
- ^ [4] Historical reporting on Hans-Joachim Bohlmann's long series of museum attacks, including damage to works by Dürer and others, with psychiatric context and without a catalogue of methods. Britannica: Albrecht Dürer Bavarian State Painting Collections
- ^ [5] Historical accounts of Mary Richardson's 10 March 1914 attack on Velázquez's Rokeby Venus at the National Gallery, London, in the context of the suffrage campaign and Pankhurst's arrest, without restaging the slashes or the figure. The National Gallery, London Britannica: Diego Velázquez
- ^ [6] Accounts of Duchamp's lost 1917 Fountain, of later authorized replicas, and of Pierre Pinoncelli's 1993 Nîmes and 2006 Centre Pompidou attacks, without a crude restaging. Centre Pompidou Britannica: Marcel Duchamp
- ^ [7] Reporting on the 2007 lipstick incident involving a Cy Twombly canvas, often identified as Phaedrus, at the Collection Lambert in Avignon, and on the subsequent legal and conservation history, without reconstruction of the work. Collection Lambert Britannica: Cy Twombly
- ^ [8] Reporting on Tony Shafrazi's 28 February 1974 spray-paint attack on Picasso's Guernica at the Museum of Modern Art, on the protest context, and on the rapid removal of the paint from a varnished surface, without reconstruction of the mural. Museum of Modern Art Britannica: Guernica
- ^ [9] Accounts of the 1986 attack on Barnett Newman's Who's Afraid of Red, Yellow and Blue III at the Stedelijk Museum, of a later second attack by the same man, and of the public controversy over the restoration, without a method or a reconstruction. Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam Britannica: Barnett Newman
- ^ [10] Reporting on the May 2018 attack on Ilya Repin's Ivan the Terrible and His Son Ivan at the Tretyakov Gallery, on the attacker's shifting account, on a 1913 precedent, and on the later restoration, without restaging the violent subject. State Tretyakov Gallery Britannica: Ilya Repin
Discussion
Log in with