4 Views 0 Comments 0 Shares

Top 10 Confident Predictions That Turned Out Wrong

Listen to this article Free TTS Play using your browser's built-in text-to-speech

Spread Your Love for Finepedia

Top 10 Confident Predictions That Turned Out Wrong

Experts have confidently predicted the impossible and the inevitable, and some of the most famous wrong forecasts were never actually made. Wrong predictions are entertaining because they come with hindsight. A forecast that sounded reasonable in its own time can look absurd a few decades later, especially when it involves technology. But collecting famous wrong predictions has its own risk. Many of the most quoted examples were exaggerated, taken out of context or never said at all.

The ten cases below are Simon Newcomb on flight, Irving Fisher on stocks in 1929, Ernest Rutherford on atomic energy, a New York Times editorial on rockets, the five-computers quotation, the patent-office quotation, the Decca audition, Ken Olsen on home computers, The Population Bomb and Steve Ballmer on the iPhone. Each is described with what was really said, as far as the record shows, and two famous examples are identified as myths.

Key Facts

#PredictionWho and whenWhat happened
1Heavier-than-air flight is impracticalSimon Newcomb, astronomer, 1901 to 1903The Wright brothers flew in December 1903
2Stock prices have reached a permanently high plateauIrving Fisher, economist, October 1929The Wall Street Crash began days later
3Talk of power from atoms is moonshineErnest Rutherford, physicist, September 1933Nuclear fission was discovered in 1938
4A rocket cannot work in a vacuumThe New York Times, January 1920Rockets reached space; the paper published a correction
5A world market for maybe five computersAttributed to Thomas Watson of IBM, 1943No evidence he said it
6Everything that can be invented has been inventedAttributed to Charles Duell, U.S. patent commissioner, 1899The quotation is a myth
7Guitar groups are on their way outAttributed to Decca executives, 1962The Beatles signed with another label
8No reason for any individual to have a computer in his homeKen Olsen, founder of Digital Equipment Corporation, 1977Personal computers became common
9Hundreds of millions will starve in the 1970sPaul Ehrlich, The Population Bomb, 1968Mass famine on that scale did not occur
10No chance the iPhone will get significant market shareSteve Ballmer, Microsoft, 2007The iPhone transformed the phone industry

1. Mathematics Against the Airplane

Simon Newcomb was one of the most respected American astronomers of his time. In essays published around 1901 to 1903, he argued that practical heavier-than-air flying machines were extremely unlikely, pointing to problems of weight, power and control [1].

In October 1903, Samuel Langley's aircraft, the Aerodrome, failed in public tests, which seemed to support the skeptics. Then on 17 December 1903, Wilbur and Orville Wright made the first controlled, powered, sustained flights at Kitty Hawk, North Carolina [1].

Newcomb's arguments were not foolish. They reflected real engineering challenges, and he was not alone in his doubts. Lord Kelvin is also often quoted as dismissing heavier-than-air flight, though the exact words attributed to him are less securely documented. The case shows how expertise in one field does not guarantee foresight about rapid developments in another.

2. A Permanently High Plateau

Irving Fisher was one of the most prominent American economists of the early twentieth century, known for important work on money and interest. In mid-October 1929, he said in a speech that stock prices had reached what looked like a permanently high plateau [2].

Within days, the market began its collapse. Black Thursday, 24 October, and Black Tuesday, 29 October, saw enormous losses, and the crash was followed by the Great Depression. Fisher lost much of his personal fortune and his public reputation suffered [2].

Economists today still respect much of Fisher's theoretical work, including ideas about debt and deflation that he developed after the crash. His 1929 comment is an example of how even skilled analysts can be caught by a bubble, especially when they have personal reasons to believe that good times will continue.

3. Atomic Energy as Moonshine

Ernest Rutherford, the pioneer of nuclear physics, said in September 1933, as reported in The Times of London, that anyone who looked for a source of power in the transformation of atoms was talking moonshine [3].

The physicist Leó Szilárd reportedly read the report and, irritated by it, began thinking about a nuclear chain reaction, an idea he patented in 1934. In 1938, Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann discovered nuclear fission, explained by Lise Meitner and Otto Frisch. By 1942, the first controlled chain reaction had been achieved in Chicago [3].

Rutherford's skepticism made sense based on the experiments of his time, in which far more energy was used to split atoms than was released. He did not foresee a chain reaction. His comment shows how a new discovery can change the meaning of an expert's careful judgment almost overnight.

Sponsored

4. An Editorial Corrected in 1969

In January 1920, The New York Times published an editorial mocking the physicist Robert Goddard, who had suggested that rockets could one day reach the Moon. The editorial claimed that a rocket would not work in the vacuum of space because it would have nothing to push against [4].

The editorial was wrong about basic physics. A rocket works by expelling mass in one direction, which pushes the rocket in the other direction, as described by Newton's third law of motion. It does not need air to push against. Goddard went on to launch the first liquid-fueled rocket in 1926 [4].

On 17 July 1969, as Apollo 11 was on its way to the Moon, the newspaper published a short correction, acknowledging that a rocket can function in a vacuum and regretting the error. The episode is a well-documented example of a confident claim corrected by events.

5. A Quotation With No Source

A widely repeated quotation attributes to Thomas Watson, the head of IBM, the claim in 1943 that there was a world market for maybe five computers. It appears in many lists of bad predictions [5].

Researchers have found no evidence that Watson said it. IBM has stated that it has no record of the quotation, and it does not appear in contemporary sources. A possibly related remark was made in the early 1950s by Watson's son, Thomas Watson Jr., who said IBM had expected orders for a handful of its 701 computers and received many more [5].

The quotation probably survives because it makes a neat story about short-sighted executives. The real history is different. IBM became the world's dominant computer company. The case is a warning that collections of wrong predictions often include invented ones.

6. A Commissioner Who Never Said It

Another well-known quotation claims that Charles Holland Duell, Commissioner of the U.S. Patent Office, said in 1899 that everything that could be invented had been invented, and that the office should be closed [6].

Historians have shown that Duell did not say this. In his official reports, he was optimistic about continuing invention and argued for improvements to the patent system. The quotation appears to have been attributed to him later, possibly by confusing him with other, older comments about the end of invention [6].

The myth persists in speeches and books about innovation. It illustrates how a misquotation can spread through repetition, especially when it fits a familiar story about bureaucrats who fail to see the future. Checking original sources can turn a famous wrong prediction into a story about wrong attribution.

7. A Record Company Passes on a Band

On 1 January 1962, the Beatles auditioned for Decca Records in London. Decca chose to sign another group, Brian Poole and the Tremeloes, instead. The Beatles later signed with Parlophone, part of EMI, and became the most successful band in popular music [7].

The executive often blamed is Dick Rowe, and the phrase usually attributed to Decca is that guitar groups were on their way out. The exact wording and who said it are uncertain, and Rowe himself disputed some versions of the story. The quotation may have been simplified over the years [7].

Rowe later signed the Rolling Stones to Decca, reportedly on the advice of George Harrison. The Decca audition shows how difficult it is to judge talent and taste in popular culture, and how one decision can become a symbol of failure, even when the full story is more complicated.

8. No Reason for a Computer at Home

Ken Olsen founded Digital Equipment Corporation, a major maker of minicomputers. In 1977, he is reported to have said that there was no reason for any individual to have a computer in his home [8].

Olsen later said the remark had been taken out of context. He explained that he was talking about computers that would control a home, such as running lights and appliances, not about personal computers in general. The quotation is real, but its meaning is disputed [8].

Still, Digital Equipment was slow to adapt to the personal computer revolution, and the company was eventually bought by Compaq in 1998. The case shows how a quotation can be both real and misleading, and how the fate of a company can make a remark seem more prophetic, or more foolish, than it was meant to be.

9. A Forecast of Mass Famine

In 1968, the biologist Paul Ehrlich published The Population Bomb, written with his wife Anne Ehrlich, though only Paul was credited at first. The book predicted that in the 1970s, hundreds of millions of people would starve to death because population growth would outrun food supplies [9].

The predicted global famine did not happen on that scale. Food production increased greatly, partly because of the Green Revolution, which introduced high-yield crops, fertilizers and irrigation. Famines did occur, but they were mostly linked to war, politics and distribution failures rather than global food shortage [9].

Ehrlich has defended the book's broader warnings about environmental limits. Critics argue that its specific predictions were badly wrong and that the book encouraged harsh population policies. The case shows how a serious concern can be weakened by forecasts that are too specific and too confident.

10. A Smartphone Dismissed

In 2007, shortly after Apple announced the iPhone, Microsoft's chief executive Steve Ballmer said in an interview that there was no chance the iPhone would get any significant market share. He pointed to its high price and lack of a keyboard [10].

The iPhone, released in June 2007, transformed the mobile phone industry. Touchscreen smartphones became the norm, and Apple became one of the most valuable companies in the world. Microsoft's own mobile efforts, including Windows Phone, failed to gain a large share [10].

Ballmer later acknowledged that he had underestimated the iPhone. His comment is often quoted, partly because it was recent and well recorded. It is a reminder that incumbents in an industry often judge new products by existing standards, such as price or keyboard design, and miss what makes them different.

Conclusion

The ten cases above show that wrong predictions come in several forms. Some were reasonable judgments overtaken by events, like Newcomb on flight or Rutherford on atomic energy. Some were driven by optimism or business interests, like Fisher in 1929 or Ballmer in 2007. And some, like the five computers and the end of invention, were never said at all.

Lists of bad predictions are popular because they flatter the reader. The more useful lesson is about uncertainty. Experts are often right about the obstacles they see and wrong about the solutions they cannot yet imagine, and the record is the best guard against quotations that are too good to be true.

What surprised you most? Tell us in the comments.

Discussion 0

0 / 5000
Comment as a guest

Questions or grievances: Dhiraj Sharma, Grievance Officer — [email protected].

Log in with
  • No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion.