For centuries, people treated the heart as the seat of the self, burying it apart from the body, carrying it on crusade and even smuggling it across borders. Long before modern medicine described the heart as a pump, many cultures treated it as the center of thought, feeling and identity. That belief led to practices that now seem strange. In ancient Egypt, the heart was weighed in the afterlife. In medieval and early modern Europe, the hearts of kings, nobles and famous people were often removed after death and buried separately, sometimes far from the body.
The ten cases below are the Egyptian weighing of the heart, the Habsburg heart crypt in Vienna, the heart of Richard the Lionheart, the heart of Robert the Bruce, the heart reliquary of Anne of Brittany, the heart of the boy king Louis XVII, the heart of Percy Bysshe Shelley, the heart of Frédéric Chopin, the heart of Thomas Hardy and the stolen heart of Saint Laurence O'Toole. The descriptions stay with history and avoid graphic detail.
Key Facts
| # | Case | Where and when | What was done with the heart |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The weighing of the heart | Ancient Egypt | Judged against a feather in the afterlife |
| 2 | The Habsburg heart crypt | Augustinian Church, Vienna, from the seventeenth century | Hearts kept in urns apart from bodies and organs |
| 3 | Richard the Lionheart | France, 1199 | Heart buried in Rouen and analyzed in 2013 |
| 4 | Robert the Bruce | Scotland and Spain, 1329 to 1330 | Taken on crusade, then buried at Melrose Abbey |
| 5 | Anne of Brittany | France, 1514 | Heart placed in a gold case and sent to Nantes |
| 6 | Louis XVII | France, 1795 and 2000 | Heart preserved, identified and buried in 2004 |
| 7 | Percy Bysshe Shelley | Italy and England, 1822 | Taken from the cremation and kept by his widow |
| 8 | Frédéric Chopin | Paris and Warsaw, 1849 | Kept in a church pillar and examined in 2014 |
| 9 | Thomas Hardy | England, 1928 | Heart buried in Dorset; ashes in Westminster Abbey |
| 10 | Saint Laurence O'Toole | Dublin, 2012 to 2018 | Stolen from a cathedral and recovered six years later |
1. A Heart on the Scales
In ancient Egyptian belief, the heart was the seat of intelligence and moral character. During mummification, many internal organs were removed, but the heart was usually left inside the body, because it would be needed in the afterlife [1].
Texts and illustrations in the Book of the Dead show the heart being weighed on a scale against a feather representing Maat, the principle of truth and order. If the heart was heavy with wrongdoing, it could be devoured by a creature called Ammit. If it balanced, the dead person could pass on [1].
Egyptians also placed heart scarabs, amulets inscribed with spells, on mummies to prevent the heart from testifying against its owner. These practices show how central the heart was to Egyptian ideas of identity and judgment, and they are among the oldest recorded beliefs about the heart as more than an organ.
2. A Crypt of Royal Hearts
Members of the Habsburg dynasty, which ruled Austria and much of central Europe, developed an unusual burial custom. Their bodies were placed in the Imperial Crypt, the Kaisergruft, in Vienna, while their hearts were kept separately in the Herzgruft, a small crypt in the Augustinian Church [2].
The Herzgruft holds dozens of silver urns containing the hearts of emperors, empresses and other family members, beginning in the seventeenth century. Other organs were placed in St. Stephen's Cathedral. This threefold burial reflected religious devotion and dynastic display [2].
The tradition continued into the nineteenth century, and a heart was added as late as the twenty-first century, when Otto von Habsburg's heart was buried in 2011 at the Pannonhalma Archabbey in Hungary. Heart burial in separate places allowed dynasties to honor several sites and was a widespread practice among European royalty.
3. A King's Heart in Rouen
Richard I of England, known as the Lionheart, died in 1199 from an infected crossbow wound while besieging a castle in France. His body was divided according to the customs of the time. His heart was taken to Rouen Cathedral in Normandy, while his body was buried at Fontevraud Abbey [3].
Related: Top 10 Most Bizarre Phobias: Strange Fears That Exist
In 2013, scientists examined the remains of the heart, which had been preserved in a lead box. They found evidence that it had been embalmed with materials including myrtle, daisy, mint, frankincense and possibly creosote or lime. These substances echo practices associated with sacred burial [3].
The study did not find evidence of poison, which had sometimes been suggested. The analysis shows how medieval embalming treated royal hearts with care and symbolism. It also shows how modern science can study objects that have been kept for many centuries.
4. A Heart Carried Toward the Holy Land
Robert the Bruce, King of Scots, died in 1329. Before his death, he asked that his heart be taken on a crusade, since he had not been able to go himself. Sir James Douglas, one of his closest companions, carried it in a casket as he set out [4].
Douglas joined a campaign in Spain against the Kingdom of Granada and was killed in battle at Teba in 1330. According to later accounts, his companions recovered the heart and brought it back to Scotland. It was buried at Melrose Abbey, while Bruce's body was buried at Dunfermline Abbey [4].
In 1921 and again in 1996, a casket believed to contain the heart was found at Melrose. In 1998, it was reburied with a memorial stone. The story of Douglas carrying the heart became part of Scottish legend and is reflected in the Douglas family coat of arms, which includes a heart.
5. A Golden Reliquary for a Queen
Anne of Brittany was Duchess of Brittany and twice Queen of France. When she died in 1514, her body was buried at the royal basilica of Saint-Denis near Paris, but her heart was placed in a gold reliquary and sent to Nantes, the capital of Brittany, to be buried with her parents [5].
The heart case is a small, enameled gold object decorated with inscriptions and crowns. It was emptied during the French Revolution, when many royal tombs were disturbed. The case itself survived and is now displayed in a museum in Nantes [5].
Related: Top 10 Oldest Buildings in the World
The reliquary was briefly stolen in 2018 and later recovered. It is an important symbol of Breton identity and of Anne's role in the history of Brittany. Her request reflects the idea that the heart, as the seat of loyalty, should rest in the place a person most loved.
6. A Child's Heart Identified by DNA
Louis-Charles, son of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette, was proclaimed Louis XVII by royalists after his father's execution. He died in prison in Paris in 1795 at the age of ten. A doctor who performed the autopsy secretly kept his heart [6].
The heart passed through several hands over the following two centuries. Because many people claimed to be the escaped prince, its identity was uncertain. In 2000, DNA from the heart was compared with DNA from hair of Marie Antoinette and from living relatives, and the results supported the conclusion that it was the heart of her son [6].
In 2004, the heart was placed in a crystal urn and buried in the Basilica of Saint-Denis, the traditional burial place of French kings. The case is an example of how modern genetic testing can resolve historical mysteries, and of how relics kept in secret can survive revolutions.
7. A Poet's Heart Kept in a Desk
The English poet Percy Bysshe Shelley drowned off the coast of Italy in 1822. His body was cremated on a beach near Viareggio, in a ceremony attended by friends including Lord Byron and Edward John Trelawny [7].
According to Trelawny's account, part of the heart did not burn, and he took it from the pyre. After some dispute among Shelley's friends, it was given to his widow, the novelist Mary Shelley. Some historians have suggested the organ may actually have been the liver, but the story of the heart became established [7].
Related: 10 Sikh Gurus: The Pillars of Sikhism Who Shaped Faith, Equality, Courage, and Humanity
Mary Shelley reportedly kept the heart, wrapped in a page of one of Shelley's poems, for the rest of her life. After her death, it was found among her possessions, and it was buried with their son, Sir Percy Florence Shelley, in 1889. The story became a famous symbol of Romantic devotion.
8. A Heart Smuggled to Warsaw
The composer Frédéric Chopin died in Paris in 1849. He had asked that his heart be returned to Poland, which was then under Russian rule. His sister, Ludwika Jędrzejewicz, took the heart, preserved in a jar of alcohol, to Warsaw, reportedly concealing it under her clothes when crossing borders [8].
The heart was placed in a pillar in the Church of the Holy Cross in Warsaw. During the Second World War, it was removed by German forces and returned after the war. It remains in the church, where it is honored as a national symbol [8].
In 2014, a team of scientists was allowed to examine the jar without opening it. A study published in 2017 concluded that Chopin probably died from complications of tuberculosis, specifically pericarditis. The heart's journey combines family loyalty, national symbolism and modern medical investigation.
9. A Writer Buried in Two Places
The novelist and poet Thomas Hardy, author of works such as Tess of the d'Urbervilles, died in 1928. He had wanted to be buried in Stinsford, the Dorset village where his family was buried. However, it was decided that he should be honored with burial in Westminster Abbey in London [9].
As a compromise, his heart was removed and buried in Stinsford churchyard, while the rest of his body was cremated and the ashes placed in Poets' Corner at Westminster Abbey. Both burials took place on the same day [9].
Related: Top 10 Tallest Buildings in the World
A popular story claims that the heart was eaten by a cat before burial and that the cat was buried in its place. There is no evidence for this, and it is generally treated as a myth. The real compromise, though less dramatic, shows how public honor and private wishes could pull a famous person's remains in two directions.
10. A Saint's Heart Stolen and Returned
Saint Laurence O'Toole was Archbishop of Dublin in the twelfth century and is the city's patron saint. His heart was preserved in a heart-shaped wooden box inside an iron cage in Christ Church Cathedral in Dublin [10].
In March 2012, the relic was stolen from the cathedral. Thieves cut through the bars of the cage and took the heart, leaving other valuable objects behind. The theft caused shock in Dublin and was widely reported [10].
In April 2018, police recovered the relic, and it was returned to the cathedral. The case shows that relics of hearts still carry religious and cultural meaning today, and that the old belief in the heart as the most important part of a person continues to shape how such objects are treated.
Conclusion
The ten cases above show how long the heart has been treated as the center of a person. From the Egyptian scales to the Habsburg urns and the hearts of Bruce, Chopin and Hardy, people chose to separate the heart from the body because they believed it carried identity, loyalty and love.
Modern science has examined several of these hearts, from Richard's embalming to Chopin's illness and Louis XVII's DNA. Those studies add facts without removing the meaning. The heart burials remain a record of how people wanted to be remembered and where they felt they belonged.
- ^ [1] Accounts of Egyptian beliefs about the heart and the Book of the Dead. Wikipedia: weighing of the heart Wikipedia: heart scarab
- ^ [2] Accounts of the Habsburg Herzgruft and heart burial. Wikipedia: Herzgruft Wikipedia: heart burial
- ^ [3] Accounts of Richard I's death and the 2013 analysis of his heart. Wikipedia: Richard I of England Wikipedia: Rouen Cathedral
- ^ [4] Accounts of Robert the Bruce's heart and James Douglas. Wikipedia: Robert the Bruce Wikipedia: James Douglas
- ^ [5] Accounts of Anne of Brittany's heart reliquary. Wikipedia: Anne of Brittany's heart case Wikipedia: Anne of Brittany
- ^ [6] Accounts of Louis XVII and the DNA testing of his heart. Wikipedia: Louis XVII Wikipedia: Basilica of Saint-Denis
- ^ [7] Accounts of Shelley's death, cremation and heart. Wikipedia: Percy Bysshe Shelley Wikipedia: Edward John Trelawny
- ^ [8] Accounts of Chopin's heart and the 2014 examination. Wikipedia: Chopin's heart Wikipedia: Holy Cross Church, Warsaw
- ^ [9] Accounts of Thomas Hardy's two burials. Wikipedia: Thomas Hardy Wikipedia: Poets' Corner
- ^ [10] Accounts of the theft and recovery of Saint Laurence O'Toole's heart. Wikipedia: Laurence O'Toole Wikipedia: Christ Church Cathedral, Dublin
Discussion
Log in with