A music-hall pastiche, a disco novelty and a meme-length dance track have all reached number one, a chart fact that does not require quoting a lyric. The Billboard Hot 100, like any chart, records what was bought, played, and, later, streamed, not what critics would have chosen [1][2][10]. The ten singles below are documented peaks, and they are discussed here as history: dates, chart runs, and the circumstances that made an odd record briefly the most prominent song in the United States [4][7]. This article will not quote lyrics, reprint album art, or describe copyrighted film characters, costumes, or props [4][9].
A novelty at the top of the chart is still a novelty. It does not have to be replayed in full in order to be explained.
Key Facts
These are Billboard Hot 100 number-one singles whose paths to the top were unusual. The entries are chart history, written without lyrics or likenesses.
Ten Chart Facts at a Glance
| Rank | Single | The unlikely part |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Winchester Cathedral, 1966 | A British music-hall pastiche, cut with session players, spent three non-consecutive weeks at number one and later won a Grammy over better-remembered records |
| 2 | Harlem Shake, 2013 | A short electronic track rose after Billboard began counting YouTube views, on the back of a meme rather than ordinary radio growth |
| 3 | Mr. Custer, 1960 | A spoken novelty about Little Bighorn reached number one; its humor has been widely criticized as racist, and this entry will not repeat the jokes |
| 4 | Love Theme from Romeo and Juliet, 1969 | An instrumental arrangement of a film theme topped the pop chart and interrupted major vocal hits |
| 5 | My Ding-a-Ling, 1972 | Chuck Berry's only Hot 100 number one was a live novelty cover, discussed here without the lyric |
| 6 | Stars on 45, 1981 | A Dutch disco medley, famous for a very long official title, spent a week at number one |
| 7 | Batdance, 1989 | A soundtrack single from a 1989 comic-book film was Prince's chart-topper, ahead of some better-known hits that had peaked at number two |
| 8 | Dominique, 1963 | A French-language religious song recorded by Jeannine Deckers reached number one; the lyric is not reproduced here |
| 9 | Star Wars Theme/Cantina Band, 1977 | A disco arrangement of a 1977 film score spent two weeks at number one; this entry does not describe the film's characters or reproduce the tune |
| 10 | Disco Duck, 1976 | A radio-host novelty with a comic animal voice spent a week at number one, and its maker was briefly barred from promoting it on his own show |
1. A Music-Hall Record, Built in the Studio
In late 1966, "Winchester Cathedral," billed to the New Vaudeville Band, reached number one on the Hot 100 and spent three non-consecutive weeks there [1]. The record was a pastiche of pre-war British variety style, written by Geoff Stephens and cut with session musicians, not with a long-standing touring group that already existed under that name [1]. The lead vocal, associated with John Carter, was delivered in a pinched, megaphone-like way that was part of the joke. When the single took off, a performing lineup was assembled, a familiar story in the era of studio-built hits. The following year the record won the Grammy for Best Contemporary (R&R) Recording, beating, to later astonishment, much more durable work from the same season, including singles by the Beach Boys and the Beatles [1].
The unlikely fact is not that a novelty can sell. It is that a manufactured music-hall ghost, in the year of more ambitious pop, could be, for three weeks, the official favorite, and then take a prize that has not aged as well as the records it beat.
2. A Meme, and a Change in the Rules
"Harlem Shake," by the producer Baauer (Harry Bauer Rodrigues), reached number one in February 2013 and stayed there for five weeks [2]. The track had been assembled the previous year from a beat, samples, and a few sound effects. It became a mass phenomenon only when short online videos, using a brief stretch of the record, spread as a meme [2]. Billboard had recently begun to include YouTube views in the Hot 100 formula, and that change, as much as radio, helps explain the sudden jump. The title points to a dance with a longer history than the meme; most of the chart audience was watching a joke video, not studying that history [2]. This article will not transcribe the track or treat the meme format as a how-to.
The unlikely fact is methodological. A short electronic record can top a national singles chart when the chart starts counting a new kind of play, and when the "song" people share is only a sliver of the file.
Related: Top 10 Best-Selling Albums of All Time
3. A Number One that Has Not Aged as a Joke
Larry Verne's "Mr. Custer" reached number one in October 1960 [3]. It is a mostly spoken novelty set around the 1876 Battle of the Little Bighorn, performed in a comic, complaining voice. The record has been widely criticized for racist language and for turning a massacre into a punch line, and those criticisms are justified [3]. This entry exists as a chart fact, not as a revival. It will not quote the lyric, retell the joke, or invite anyone to enjoy the stereotype. For a week or so, this was the most prominent single in the country, and it even sat ahead of stronger, more durable records on the same chart [3].
The unlikely, and uncomfortable, fact is that a novelty this sour could be a national number one. The decent way to write that sentence is to stop there, without handing the song a second life in these paragraphs.
4. A Quiet Theme at the Top of a Loud Chart
In 1969, Henry Mancini's "Love Theme from Romeo and Juliet," an instrumental arrangement of music associated with Franco Zeffirelli's film, spent time at number one on the Hot 100 [4]. The film itself had been scored by Nino Rota; Mancini's single was a separate, popular arrangement, heavy on melody and light on the vocal hooks that usually rule the pop chart [4]. It is remembered, among chart historians, for interrupting the reign of the Beatles' "Get Back" and for keeping Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Bad Moon Rising" at bay. This article will not reproduce the theme, in notation or in a long descriptive reconstruction. The fact is the peak: a gentle instrumental, tied to a much-told story, can still, in a particular summer, out-rank the louder singles around it [4].
Unlikely, here, means stylistically unlikely. The chart is sometimes in the mood for a theme, and that mood can be brief and decisive.
5. The One Number One, and Not the Famous Ones
Chuck Berry's only number-one single on the Hot 100 was not one of the 1950s records that defined early rock and roll. It was a 1972 live performance of "My Ding-a-Ling," a novelty he had taken from Dave Bartholomew, recorded at a festival in England and then issued as a single [5]. The song is a joke record, and this article will not quote it, unpack the innuendo, or treat the chorus as entertainment copy. Berry had already changed popular music with work that never reached the same official peak. The unlikely fact is statistical: a career of essential singles, and a number one that almost no serious listener would put first on a list of his achievements [5].
Related: Top 10 Famous Bands That Began with Worse Names
Chart peaks are a poor measure of importance. This is one of the cleaner proofs of that rule, and it can be stated without singing the joke.
6. A Medley with a Title Longer than the Joke
In 1981, a Dutch studio project known as Stars on 45 spent a week at number one in the United States with a disco medley that stitched together fragments of older hits, many of them associated with the Beatles, over a persistent dance beat [6]. The official title, a stack of the song names used in the medley, is often cited as the longest to have topped the Hot 100; everyday listeners shortened it to "Stars on 45" [6]. The project grew out of a publishing and studio response to unofficial medleys already circulating. This article will not list the fragments as a lyric sheet or reconstruct the sequence so that it can be performed from the paragraph. The chart fact is the peak, and the cultural fact is a moment of heavy nostalgia, including a renewed hunger for Beatles-era sounds in the months after John Lennon's murder in December 1980 [6].
A medley is a way of selling memory by the yard. For one week, that was enough.
7. A Soundtrack Single, Without the Costumes
Prince's "Batdance," released in connection with the soundtrack of a 1989 comic-book film, reached number one on the Hot 100 [7]. Some of his better-known earlier singles, including "Purple Rain" and "Raspberry Beret," had stopped at number two. The 1989 track is a choppy, collage-like dance record, assembled with a free hand rather than as a scene-by-scene illustration, and it used pieces of the film's sound world among other parts [7]. This article will not describe copyrighted characters, quote lines from the film, or restage a poster. The unlikely fact is the ranking: a soundtrack oddity, in a year when the artist's more canonical songs were already behind him on the chart, can still be the one that officially went all the way [7].
A number one is a week, or a few, in the life of a catalog. It is not a verdict on which record was the best.
Related: Top 10 Albums That Were Panned and Later Became Classics
8. A French Hymn on an American Chart
At the end of 1963, "Dominique," recorded by Jeannine Deckers, a Belgian nun who performed as Sœur Sourire, or the Singing Nun, reached number one on the Hot 100 [8]. It is a French-language religious song, unusual at the top of a mainly English-speaking pop chart, and this article will not reproduce the lyric. Commentators have sometimes linked its American success to a public mood after the assassination of President Kennedy, which is a plausible atmosphere and not a proof [8]. Deckers's later life was marked by a loss of control over the record's rewards, by a departure from her convent, and by serious financial and personal hardship; she died in 1985 [8]. The chart fact can be told without turning that ending into a spectacle.
The unlikely peak is a quiet, foreign-language single in a loud market. The human fact, kept brief, is that a number one is not the same thing as a secure life.
9. A Film Score, Recast for a Dance Floor
In 1977, the producer Domenico Monardo, working as Meco, reached number one for two weeks with "Star Wars Theme/Cantina Band," a disco arrangement drawn from John Williams's score for a then-new science-fiction film [9]. The single is a documented case of a popular film music theme crossing, almost immediately, onto the dance chart and then to the top of the Hot 100 [9]. This article will not describe the film's characters, creatures, ships, or typography, and it will not reconstruct the melody in words or in notation. The unlikely part is speed and translation: a symphonic theme, only weeks old as a mass-cultural object, could be recast with a disco beat and sold as a single that out-danced many records written for that beat from the start [9].
The chart does not care whether a tune began in a cinema. It cares, in a given week, what people played and bought.
Related: Top 10 Most Bizarre Phobias: Strange Fears That Exist
10. A Radio Novelty, Briefly Unmentionable at Work
"Disco Duck," credited to Rick Dees and His Cast of Idiots, spent a week at number one in October 1976 [10]. It is a disco parody built around a comic animal voice, and this article will not quote the lyric or attach that voice to any copyrighted cartoon character [10]. Dees was a radio host, and his own station, treating the record as a conflict of interest, restricted him from promoting it; a mention of the single was enough, in the standard version of the story, to cost him that job, after which he was soon hired elsewhere [10]. The unlikely fact is double: a joke record at number one, and a hit its own maker was not supposed to advertise on the air.
A parody can be a genuine commercial event. It remains, after the week has passed, a novelty, which is the right size for it on a list like this.
Conclusion
The Hot 100 has room, in ordinary years, for records that later look like accidents: a music-hall pastiche, a spoken novelty that should not be revived as a joke, a meme fragment, a quiet film theme, a medley, a soundtrack collage, a French hymn, a disco recasting of a film score, and a duck-voiced parody. Chuck Berry's only official number one belongs on that shelf too, not because his better work failed, but because charts are blunt instruments. None of these entries needs a lyric, a sleeve, or a copyrighted face in order to be understood. The dates, the weeks at the top, and the conditions of sale are the facts.
Unlikely, in this context, is not the same as inexplicable. It means that the chart, for a moment, pointed at something almost no one would have predicted, and then moved on.
- ^ [1] Billboard and Grammy records for "Winchester Cathedral" by the New Vaudeville Band, 1966-67. Britannica and contemporary chart histories of the 1966 single
- ^ [2] Billboard methodology changes and chart runs for "Harlem Shake" by Baauer, 2013. Britannica: Billboard, and contemporaneous chart reporting
- ^ [3] Chart documentation of Larry Verne's "Mr. Custer," 1960, discussed here as a historical peak and not as a lyric to be repeated. Britannica: Battle of the Little Bighorn, and standard Hot 100 histories
- ^ [4] Chart histories of Henry Mancini's "Love Theme from Romeo and Juliet," 1969. Britannica: Henry Mancini
- ^ [5] Chart records of Chuck Berry's 1972 number-one single, identified without quotation of the lyric. Britannica: Chuck Berry
- ^ [6] Chart and industry accounts of the Stars on 45 medley, 1981, without a reconstructed track list for performance. Britannica: Disco, and contemporaneous chart reporting
- ^ [7] Billboard peaks for Prince, including the 1989 soundtrack single "Batdance," described without film characters or quoted dialogue. Britannica: Prince
- ^ [8] Chart records for "Dominique" and biographical summaries of Jeannine Deckers, with the lyric omitted. Britannica: The Singing Nun
- ^ [9] Chart documentation of Meco's 1977 film-theme disco single, described without character designs or musical notation. Britannica: Disco, and contemporaneous chart reporting
- ^ [10] Chart and radio-industry accounts of "Disco Duck," 1976, without lyrics or copyrighted cartoon likenesses. Britannica: Novelty song, and contemporaneous reporting
Discussion
Log in with