Did Henry VIII write Greensleeves? Did Salieri poison Mozart? Ten common misconceptions about music history, and what the evidence actually shows. Music history is full of great stories. Some of the most famous concern legendary composers, mysterious musicians and the origins of well-loved songs. Unfortunately, many of these stories are not true.
Myths about music spread for many reasons. Some began as rumors or jokes, while others grew from plays, films and novels that took liberties with history. Once a good story takes hold, it can be repeated so often that it becomes accepted as fact.
Other misconceptions come from simple confusion. A composer may be credited with a tune he only arranged, or an inventor may be credited with an achievement that someone else accomplished first.
Correcting these myths does not make music history less interesting. In many cases, the truth is just as fascinating as the legend, and it often reveals more about the people and times involved.
The misconceptions below cover medieval chant, Tudor songs, classical composers, early recording technology, blues legends, pop stars and modern claims about music and intelligence.
Some of them have been repeated in textbooks, documentaries and popular articles for generations. Others spread more recently through the internet and popular culture.
Each entry names the misconception, summarizes what is often believed and explains what the evidence actually shows, based on the work of historians and researchers.
Where the truth remains uncertain, that is noted. Music history, like all history, depends on surviving evidence, and some questions may never be fully answered.
The entries are arranged roughly in chronological order of the music or events involved, from the early Middle Ages to the late twentieth century.
Together, they show how easily legends can replace facts, and why it is worth looking more closely at even the most familiar stories.
Key Facts
| # | Misconception | What is often believed | What the evidence shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gregorian chant | Pope Gregory the Great composed it | It developed over centuries and was named after him later |
| 2 | Greensleeves | King Henry VIII wrote it for Anne Boleyn | It probably dates from after his death |
| 3 | Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star | Mozart composed the melody | The tune was a French song he used for variations |
| 4 | Antonio Salieri | Salieri poisoned Mozart out of jealousy | There is no evidence of poisoning, and the two were colleagues |
| 5 | Beethoven's deafness | Beethoven was deaf for his whole career | He lost his hearing gradually over many years |
| 6 | Edison and the phonograph | Thomas Edison made the first sound recording | Earlier recordings were made with a device called the phonautograph |
| 7 | Robert Johnson | He sold his soul to the devil for musical talent | The legend developed from folklore and later retellings |
| 8 | Cass Elliot | She choked to death on a sandwich | She died of heart failure |
| 9 | The Paul is dead rumor | Paul McCartney died in 1966 and was replaced | McCartney is alive and has continued to perform |
| 10 | The Mozart effect | Listening to Mozart raises children's intelligence | The original study found a small, temporary effect in adults |
1. Who Wrote Gregorian Chant?
Gregorian chant, the traditional plainchant of the Western church, is named after Pope Gregory I, who led the church at the end of the sixth century. A popular medieval legend claimed that Gregory received the chants directly from the Holy Spirit, which was often shown in art as a dove whispering in his ear [1].
Related: Top 10 Famous Bands That Began with Worse Names
Historians now believe that Gregorian chant developed over a long period, largely in the Frankish lands of western Europe during the eighth and ninth centuries. It combined Roman and local traditions of church music [1].
The connection with Pope Gregory appears to have been made later, perhaps to give the chant greater authority. Gregory may have helped organize church music during his time, but there is no evidence that he composed the chants that bear his name.
2. The King's Song
Greensleeves is one of the most famous English folk songs, and a popular story claims that it was written by King Henry VIII for Anne Boleyn. Henry was a capable musician who composed several pieces, so the story seemed plausible [2].
However, the earliest known references to Greensleeves date from 1580, decades after Henry's death in 1547. The song's style is also based on an Italian musical pattern that reached England after his death [2].
Most historians therefore believe that Henry did not write the song. The legend probably developed because of his reputation as a musician and his famous romance with Anne Boleyn.
3. Mozart and the Little Star
Many people believe that Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart composed the melody used for Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star. In fact, the tune comes from a French song called Ah! vous dirai-je, maman, which was already popular in the eighteenth century [3].
Mozart wrote a set of twelve variations for piano on the melody, probably in the early 1780s. His variations became well known, which may explain why the tune is often associated with him [3].
The words of Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star come from a poem by the English writer Jane Taylor, published in 1806. The same melody is also used for the alphabet song and Baa, Baa, Black Sheep.
4. The Rival Who Poisoned Mozart
A famous legend claims that the composer Antonio Salieri poisoned Mozart out of jealousy. The story was popularized by Alexander Pushkin's 1830 play Mozart and Salieri and later by Peter Shaffer's play Amadeus and its 1984 film adaptation [4].
Rumors that Salieri had poisoned Mozart did circulate in Vienna in the 1820s, when Salieri was elderly and ill. However, there is no evidence that Mozart was poisoned, and historians generally believe he died of illness [4].
Related: Top 10 Songs and Products That Became Hits the Second Time
Salieri was a successful and respected composer and teacher, whose students included Beethoven, Schubert and Liszt. He and Mozart were rivals in some ways, but they also worked together, and Salieri conducted some of Mozart's music.
5. The Composer Who Could Not Hear
Ludwig van Beethoven is famous for continuing to compose after losing his hearing. Some people assume that he was deaf throughout his career, or that he was born deaf [5].
In fact, Beethoven began to lose his hearing in his late twenties, around 1798. The loss progressed gradually over many years, and he was able to perform and conduct for much of his early career [5].
By the last decade of his life, he was almost completely deaf. He composed some of his greatest works, including his Ninth Symphony and late string quartets, during this period, relying on his inner understanding of music.
6. The First Recording of Sound
Thomas Edison is often credited with making the first sound recording when he invented the phonograph in 1877. Edison's machine was indeed the first that could record sound and play it back [6].
However, sound had been recorded earlier. In 1857, the French inventor Édouard-Léon Scott de Martinville patented the phonautograph, which recorded sound waves as lines on paper blackened by smoke. It was designed to study sound visually, not to play it back [6].
In 2008, researchers used modern technology to play back some of Scott's recordings, including a recording from 1860 of a voice singing part of the French song Au clair de la lune. It is one of the oldest known recordings of a human voice.
7. The Bluesman at the Crossroads
The blues musician Robert Johnson, who recorded in the 1930s, is the subject of a famous legend. According to the story, he met the devil at a crossroads in Mississippi and sold his soul in exchange for his remarkable skill on the guitar [7].
The crossroads legend draws on older folk traditions in the American South. Similar stories were told about other musicians, including the bluesman Tommy Johnson, who was not related to Robert [7].
Related: Top 10 Chance Meetings That Formed Famous Bands
Johnson's talent seems to have improved significantly over a short period, which may have contributed to the legend. Historians believe he worked hard and learned from other musicians. His recordings influenced later rock musicians, and the legend has added to his fame.
8. The Singer and the Sandwich
Cass Elliot, a member of the Mamas and the Papas, died in London in 1974. A widely repeated rumor claimed that she had choked on a ham sandwich [8].
The rumor apparently began because a sandwich was found in her room, and early speculation mentioned it. However, the medical examination found that she had died of heart failure, and no food was found obstructing her airway [8].
Despite this, the sandwich story became a persistent myth, repeated in jokes and popular culture for decades. Her family and friends have expressed frustration with the rumor.
9. A Beatle Who Never Died
In 1969, a rumor spread that Paul McCartney of the Beatles had died in a car crash in 1966 and been secretly replaced by a lookalike. Fans claimed to find clues in album covers and song lyrics [9].
The rumor was widely discussed on radio and in newspapers. Some fans believed that the cover of the album Abbey Road, which showed McCartney barefoot, symbolized a funeral procession [9].
McCartney gave interviews to deny the story, and he has continued to perform and record for decades. He has sometimes joked about the rumor, which became one of the most famous conspiracy theories in music history.
10. Music That Makes Babies Smarter
In 1993, researchers published a study suggesting that college students who listened to a Mozart sonata performed slightly better on certain spatial reasoning tasks for a short time afterward. The finding became known as the Mozart effect [10].
The idea was quickly exaggerated. Many people came to believe that playing classical music to babies would make them smarter, and products were marketed on this basis. One American state even considered providing classical music recordings to new parents [10].
Related: Top 10 Best-Selling Albums of All Time
Later research found that the original effect was small, short-lived and difficult to reproduce. Researchers have suggested that any benefit may be linked to improved mood or alertness rather than anything special about Mozart's music.
Conclusion
Music history is full of myths that have been repeated so often they are widely accepted as fact. Some began as rumors, while others grew out of plays, films or exaggerated reports of scientific studies.
Correcting these misconceptions reveals stories that are often just as interesting as the legends. Salieri was a respected teacher, Beethoven composed masterpieces as his hearing faded and sound was recorded long before Edison.
These myths also show how easily stories can spread, especially when they are dramatic or emotionally appealing.
Historians and researchers continue to study the past, using surviving documents, recordings and scientific evidence to separate fact from fiction.
The next time you hear a surprising story about a famous musician, it may be worth asking where the story came from.
Asking that question can lead to discoveries that make the music itself more meaningful, revealing the real people, places and circumstances behind it.
The truth about music history may sometimes be less dramatic than the legends, but it is often more rewarding.
- ^ [1] Accounts of Gregorian chant. Wikipedia: Gregorian chant Wikipedia: Pope Gregory I
- ^ [2] Accounts of Greensleeves. Wikipedia: Greensleeves Wikipedia: Henry VIII
- ^ [3] Accounts of Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star. Wikipedia: Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star Wikipedia: Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
- ^ [4] Accounts of Antonio Salieri. Wikipedia: Antonio Salieri Wikipedia: Amadeus (film)
- ^ [5] Accounts of Beethoven's deafness. Wikipedia: Ludwig van Beethoven Wikipedia: Symphony No. 9
- ^ [6] Accounts of the phonautograph. Wikipedia: Phonautograph Wikipedia: Édouard-Léon Scott de Martinville
- ^ [7] Accounts of Robert Johnson. Wikipedia: Robert Johnson Wikipedia: Crossroads (folklore)
- ^ [8] Accounts of Cass Elliot. Wikipedia: Cass Elliot Wikipedia: The Mamas and the Papas
- ^ [9] Accounts of the Paul is dead rumor. Wikipedia: Paul is dead Wikipedia: Paul McCartney
- ^ [10] Accounts of the Mozart effect. Wikipedia: Mozart effect Wikipedia: Spatial ability
Discussion
Log in with