3 Views 0 Comments 0 Shares

Top 10 Strange Facts About Popes Through History

Listen to this article Free TTS Play using your browser's built-in text-to-speech

Spread Your Love for Finepedia

Top 10 Strange Facts About Popes Through History

A corpse put on trial, a man who was pope three times, a pet elephant and a 13-day papacy: ten strange facts from two thousand years of popes. The papacy is one of the oldest continuously functioning institutions in the world. Since the early centuries of Christianity, around 267 men have served as bishop of Rome, the most recent being Leo XIV, elected in 2025 as the first pope born in the United States.

Over that long history, the office has been held by saints, scholars and reformers, but also by teenagers, political appointees and men caught up in violent power struggles. In the Middle Ages especially, Roman noble families fought over the papacy, and emperors and kings tried to control it.

Some of the strangest episodes come from those turbulent centuries, recorded by chroniclers who were not always neutral. Others involve legends that historians have since examined and rejected.

The ten facts below draw on official records and the work of historians, and note where accounts are disputed.

Key Facts

#Pope or eventDateWhy it stands out
1Cadaver Synod897A corpse in the dock
2Benedict IX1032 to 1048Sold the papacy and came back
3Election of 1268 to 12711268 to 1271Almost three years without a pope
4Celestine V1294Stepped down after five months
5Pope JoanLegend from the thirteenth centuryWidely believed for centuries
6Leo X and Hanno1514 to 1516A white elephant in Rome
7Urban VII1590The shortest papacy
8Sylvester II999 to 1003Brought new numerals to Europe
9Pope-elect Stephen752Caused confusion in numbering
10Adrian IV1154 to 1159A legend about a fly

1. A Dead Pope Put on Trial

In January 897, Pope Stephen VI ordered the body of his predecessor, Pope Formosus, who had died months earlier, to be dug up and put on trial. The corpse was dressed in papal robes and propped on a throne, while a deacon answered questions on its behalf [1].

Formosus was found guilty of breaking church rules, and his election was declared invalid. The fingers he had used to give blessings were cut off, and his body was thrown into the Tiber River [1].

The trial provoked outrage in Rome. Within months, Stephen VI was deposed and imprisoned, and he was strangled in prison. Later popes annulled the trial's verdict, and Formosus's body was reportedly recovered from the river and reburied. A few years later, however, Pope Sergius III, who had taken part in the original synod, is said to have reaffirmed its verdict. The church later ruled that no deceased person could be put on trial.

2. The Man Who Was Pope Three Times

Benedict IX, a member of the powerful Tusculum family, became pope around 1032 while still a young man. Chroniclers accused him of a scandalous lifestyle, though some of their claims may have been exaggerated [2].

He was driven out of Rome in 1044 but returned in 1045. Soon afterward, he sold the papacy to his godfather, who became Gregory VI. Benedict later tried to reclaim the office and briefly held it again in 1047 and 1048 [2].

He is the only person to have served as pope on more than one occasion, and he did so three times. The confusion led the German king Henry III to intervene and depose the rival claimants at the Council of Sutri in 1046. Benedict's exact age when he first became pope is uncertain. Some older accounts claimed he was only a boy, but modern historians generally think he was in his twenties.

3. The Conclave That Lost Its Roof

After the death of Pope Clement IV in 1268, the cardinals gathered in the city of Viterbo to elect his successor. Divided by politics, they failed to agree for almost three years, the longest papal election in history [3].

Frustrated local authorities locked the cardinals inside the bishop's palace, reduced their food to bread and water and, according to accounts, removed the roof to hurry them along. The cardinals finally chose Teobaldo Visconti, who was not a cardinal and was away on crusade. He became Gregory X [3].

To prevent such delays, Gregory X issued rules in 1274 requiring cardinals to be secluded during elections and to receive less food the longer they took. These rules established the modern conclave, from the Latin for with a key. The rules were briefly suspended by later popes but were restored and remain the basis of papal elections today. Cardinals are still locked away from the outside world during a conclave, and every conclave since 1878 has been held in the Sistine Chapel.

Sponsored

4. A Hermit Who Resigned

In 1294, after another two-year deadlock, the cardinals elected Pietro da Morrone, an elderly hermit known for his holiness. He took the name Celestine V [4].

Overwhelmed by the job and manipulated by political interests, Celestine issued a decree allowing popes to resign and then resigned after about five months. His successor, Boniface VIII, kept him confined in a castle, where he died in 1296 [4].

Celestine was later declared a saint. When Benedict XVI resigned in 2013, he became the first pope to do so voluntarily since Celestine. Four years earlier, Benedict had visited Celestine's tomb in L'Aquila and left his own pallium, a papal vestment, on it. The poet Dante Alighieri placed an unnamed figure who made the great refusal at the entrance to Hell, and many readers have identified that figure as Celestine. Celestine's decree on resignation remains part of church law.

5. A Female Pope Who Never Existed

According to a legend that became popular in the thirteenth century, a woman disguised as a man rose through the church and was elected pope in the ninth century. Her secret was supposedly revealed when she gave birth during a procession [5].

The story was repeated in many chronicles and was widely believed for centuries. In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, however, scholars showed that there was no room in the records for such a pope and that the story had appeared hundreds of years after her supposed reign [5].

Historians today regard Pope Joan as a legend, possibly a satire or a story that grew from local traditions. She remains a popular subject in novels and films. A related legend claimed that later popes were checked on a special chair to make sure they were men, but historians have found no evidence for the practice.

6. The Pope's Pet Elephant

In 1514, King Manuel I of Portugal sent Pope Leo X a remarkable gift: a young white elephant from India, named Hanno. The elephant was paraded through Rome and became a favorite of the pope and the public [6].

Hanno lived at the Vatican for about two years and took part in processions. In 1516, he fell ill and was treated with a medicine that reportedly included gold, but he died soon afterward [6].

Leo X was deeply saddened and wrote an epitaph for his elephant. Raphael painted a memorial fresco, which has since been lost. In 1962, workers at the Vatican found bones believed to be Hanno's. The elephant had been part of a lavish Portuguese embassy that also included exotic animals and gifts of jewels, intended to impress the pope. The historian Silvio Bedini wrote a book about Hanno, which remains the main study of the animal's life.

7. Thirteen Days and a Smoking Ban

Giovanni Battista Castagna was elected pope in September 1590, taking the name Urban VII. He died of malaria just thirteen days later, before he could be crowned, making his the shortest papacy in history [7].

In his brief time in office, he is credited with what is often described as the first known public smoking ban. He threatened to excommunicate anyone who used tobacco in or near a church, whether by chewing, smoking or sniffing it [7].

Urban VII was also known for his charity. He left his fortune to provide dowries for poor young women so that they could marry. He had previously served as a papal diplomat and governor in several cities. The conclave that followed his death lasted about two months, and the next two popes both died within about fifteen months of his own death.

8. A Mathematician on the Throne

Gerbert of Aurillac, who became Pope Sylvester II in 999, was one of the most learned men of his time. As a young monk, he studied in Catalonia, where he was exposed to mathematics and astronomy from the Islamic world [8].

He helped introduce Hindu-Arabic numerals to parts of Europe through a type of abacus, and he built astronomical instruments. He was the first French pope [8].

His learning made some people suspicious. Later legends claimed that he had made a pact with the devil and owned a magical brass head that answered questions, stories that tell more about medieval attitudes than about Gerbert himself. He was also tutor to the young emperor Otto III, whose support helped him become pope. Gerbert wrote works on mathematics, logic and music, and his letters are an important source for the period.

9. A Pope Who Was Removed From the List

In March 752, a priest named Stephen was elected pope but died of a stroke three days later, before being consecrated as bishop. For centuries, he was included in some lists of popes and excluded from others [9].

As a result, later popes named Stephen have two numbers. The pope often called Stephen II is also known as Stephen III, and so on up to Stephen IX, sometimes called Stephen X [9].

In 1961, the Vatican removed the pope-elect Stephen from its official list of popes, on the grounds that he had never been consecrated. The double numbering still appears in history books. The numbering of popes has caused other confusion too. There was never a Pope John XX, because of errors in medieval lists, so the numbering of the Johns skips from XIX to XXI.

10. The Only English Pope

Nicholas Breakspear, born in England, became Pope Adrian IV in 1154. He remains the only Englishman ever to hold the office [10].

He is associated with a papal document, known as Laudabiliter, that supposedly gave King Henry II of England permission to invade Ireland. Historians debate whether the document is genuine and what it meant [10].

According to a later story, Adrian died in 1159 after choking on a fly that had fallen into his wine. Historians consider it more likely that he died of a throat infection. Before becoming pope, Breakspear had served as a papal legate in Scandinavia, where he reorganized the church in Norway and Sweden. He was buried in St. Peter's Basilica.

Conclusion

These episodes show that the history of the papacy includes not only religious leadership but also politics, rivalry and human frailty.

Many of the strangest events occurred during the Middle Ages, when the papacy was entangled with powerful families and rulers. Reforms over the centuries made the office more stable and established modern procedures such as the conclave.

Legends, such as Pope Joan and the fly in Adrian IV's wine, show how stories can grow around famous figures.

The papacy continues to evolve, as recent resignations and the election of popes from the Americas demonstrate.

What surprised you most? Tell us in the comments.

Discussion 0

0 / 5000
Comment as a guest

Questions or grievances: Dhiraj Sharma, Grievance Officer — [email protected].

Log in with
  • No comments yet. Be the first to join the discussion.