Surprise has decided battles from a Dutch raid on English docks to a winter crossing of the Delaware, and many surprises followed warnings nobody acted on. Military theorists have long treated surprise as one of the most powerful advantages in war. A force that strikes when and where the enemy does not expect can win out of proportion to its size. Yet surprise is rarely total. In many famous cases, warnings existed, but they were dismissed, misread or lost in bureaucracy.
The ten attacks below are the Raid on the Medway, Trenton, Port Arthur, Taranto, the German advance through the Ardennes, Operation Barbarossa, Pearl Harbor, Inchon, the opening air strikes of the Six-Day War and the start of the Yom Kippur War. They are described with their strategic effects rather than in graphic detail.
Key Facts
| # | Attack | When and who | Why it mattered |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Raid on the Medway | June 1667, Dutch Republic against England | Humiliated England and helped end a war |
| 2 | Trenton | December 1776, Continental Army against Hessian troops | Revived American morale at a low point |
| 3 | Port Arthur | February 1904, Japan against Russia | Opened the Russo-Japanese War |
| 4 | Taranto | November 1940, Britain against Italy | Showed the power of carrier-borne aircraft |
| 5 | The Ardennes, 1940 | May 1940, Germany against France and its allies | Led to the fall of France in six weeks |
| 6 | Operation Barbarossa | June 1941, Germany and its allies against the Soviet Union | Opened the war on the Eastern Front |
| 7 | Pearl Harbor | December 1941, Japan against the United States | Brought the United States into the Second World War |
| 8 | Inchon | September 1950, United Nations forces against North Korea | Reversed the course of the Korean War |
| 9 | Operation Focus | June 1967, Israel against Egypt | Decided the air war in the first hours of the Six-Day War |
| 10 | The Yom Kippur War | October 1973, Egypt and Syria against Israel | Showed the danger of a fixed intelligence assumption |
1. A Dutch Fleet in an English River
During the Second Anglo-Dutch War, England had laid up much of its fleet in the River Medway at Chatham to save money while peace talks continued. In June 1667, a Dutch fleet under Michiel de Ruyter, with planning by Johan de Witt, sailed into the Thames estuary and up the Medway [1].
The Dutch broke through a chain across the river, burned several English warships and towed away the flagship, the Royal Charles. Its stern decoration is still displayed in the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam. The raid caused panic in London [1].
The Treaty of Breda was signed weeks later on terms more favorable to the Dutch than they might otherwise have obtained. The raid is often called one of the worst defeats in the history of the Royal Navy. It shows how a navy weakened by budget cuts and complacency can be struck at its own base.
2. A River Crossing on Christmas Night
By December 1776, the American cause in the Revolutionary War seemed to be failing. George Washington's army had been driven out of New York and across New Jersey, and many soldiers' enlistments were about to expire [2].
On the night of 25 to 26 December, Washington led about 2,400 troops across the icy Delaware River and marched on Trenton, New Jersey, held by Hessian soldiers in British service. The attack on the morning of 26 December surprised the garrison, and around 900 Hessians were captured [2].
The victory, followed by another at Princeton days later, restored confidence in the Continental Army and encouraged reenlistment. The crossing became an iconic image in American history. The battle was small in scale, but its timing made it one of the most important of the war.
3. A Night Attack Before a Declaration
On the night of 8 to 9 February 1904, Japanese torpedo boats attacked the Russian Pacific Fleet at its base at Port Arthur in Manchuria. Japan's formal declaration of war followed shortly afterward. The attack damaged several Russian ships [3].
Related: Pearl Harbor Did Not Happen in a Vacuum
The Russo-Japanese War that followed ended in a Japanese victory, including the destruction of a Russian fleet at the Battle of Tsushima in 1905. It was the first major victory of an Asian power over a European power in the modern era, and it had a strong impact on the politics of both countries [3].
Historians have often compared Port Arthur with Pearl Harbor in 1941, since both involved a Japanese attack on an enemy fleet at the start of a war. The comparison is imperfect, but Port Arthur showed the value of striking a fleet before it could act, a lesson that military planners around the world noted.
4. Biplanes Against a Battle Fleet
On the night of 11 to 12 November 1940, aircraft from the British carrier HMS Illustrious attacked the Italian fleet at anchor in the harbor of Taranto in southern Italy. The attackers flew Fairey Swordfish, slow biplanes that seemed outdated even then [4].
The aircraft used torpedoes adapted for shallow water and badly damaged several Italian battleships. The Italian fleet moved its main units further north, reducing its threat in the Mediterranean for a time. British losses were very small [4].
Japanese naval officers studied the raid closely, and it is often cited as an influence on the planning of the attack on Pearl Harbor a year later. Taranto showed that battleships in harbor were vulnerable to aircraft, a lesson that changed naval warfare and helped make the aircraft carrier the dominant warship.
5. Tanks Through a Forest
In May 1940, Allied commanders expected the main German attack in the west to come through central Belgium, as in the First World War. Allied forces moved into Belgium to meet it. Instead, the main German armored force advanced through the Ardennes, a wooded and hilly region thought to be unsuitable for large tank formations [5].
German forces crossed the Meuse River at Sedan and other points and drove toward the English Channel, cutting off Allied armies in Belgium. The plan, associated with Erich von Manstein, exploited a weakly defended part of the front [5].
Related: Top 10 Overlooked Events of World War II
The result was the encirclement of large Allied forces, the evacuation at Dunkirk and the surrender of France in June 1940. The campaign is often used as an example of how surprise in place and method, rather than time, can decide a campaign. The Ardennes had been considered a barrier and became a highway.
6. The Largest Invasion in History
On 22 June 1941, Germany and its allies invaded the Soviet Union with around three million soldiers along a front of more than 2,000 kilometers. Despite many warnings from intelligence sources and diplomats, Joseph Stalin had refused to believe that an attack was imminent [6].
Soviet forces were badly unprepared, and German forces advanced rapidly, capturing huge numbers of prisoners. Much of the Soviet air force was destroyed on the ground in the first days. By late 1941, German forces were near Moscow [6].
The invasion did not achieve its goal of defeating the Soviet Union quickly. The Red Army held Moscow in the winter of 1941, and the war on the Eastern Front became the largest and deadliest theater of the Second World War. Barbarossa is a classic example of a strategic surprise caused by a leader's refusal to accept warnings.
7. An Attack Expected Somewhere Else
On 7 December 1941, aircraft from six Japanese carriers attacked the U.S. Pacific Fleet at Pearl Harbor in Hawaii. The attack sank or damaged several battleships and many other ships and aircraft, and more than 2,400 Americans were killed [7].
U.S. officials knew that war with Japan was likely and had decoded some Japanese diplomatic messages. But many expected an attack in Southeast Asia or the Philippines, not Hawaii, and warnings to commanders in Hawaii were not specific enough. A radar sighting on the morning of the attack was misinterpreted [7].
Related: Germany's Invasion of Poland Began the War in Europe
The attack brought the United States into the war, and the U.S. carriers, which were not in port, survived. The intelligence failures were investigated repeatedly. Pearl Harbor became the defining American example of surprise attack and shaped later thinking about intelligence and readiness.
8. A Landing Where Tides Seemed to Forbid It
In the summer of 1950, North Korean forces had pushed South Korean and United Nations troops into a small area around Busan. General Douglas MacArthur proposed an amphibious landing far behind enemy lines at Inchon, near Seoul [8].
Inchon was a difficult site, with very large tides, mudflats and sea walls. Many officers opposed the plan. MacArthur argued that the difficulty would make the landing a surprise. On 15 September 1950, the landing succeeded, and UN forces recaptured Seoul within two weeks [8].
The landing cut North Korean supply lines and led to a rapid advance north. That advance later provoked Chinese intervention, which changed the war again. Inchon is often cited as an example of a bold amphibious operation that succeeded because the enemy did not believe it was possible.
9. A Morning Strike on Airfields
On the morning of 5 June 1967, the Israeli Air Force launched a large air strike against Egyptian airfields. The timing was chosen for a period when many Egyptian pilots and commanders were expected to be on the ground or in transit, and the aircraft flew at low altitude to avoid radar [9].
The strike destroyed a large part of the Egyptian air force on the ground within hours. Israeli strikes against the air forces of Jordan and Syria followed later that day. Air superiority gave Israeli ground forces a major advantage throughout the war [9].
Related: The Eastern Front Was the Largest Theatre of the War
The war lasted six days and ended with Israel in control of Sinai, Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, with long-lasting political consequences. Operation Focus is studied as one of the most effective air campaigns in modern history and as an example of a preemptive strike.
10. An Attack on a Holy Day
On 6 October 1973, on the Jewish holy day of Yom Kippur, Egypt and Syria launched coordinated attacks against Israeli forces in Sinai and on the Golan Heights. Egyptian forces crossed the Suez Canal and broke through Israeli defensive lines [10].
Israeli intelligence had received warnings but was strongly influenced by an assessment that Egypt would not go to war without certain military capabilities. Mobilization of reserves began only hours before the attack. Israeli forces suffered heavy losses in the first days before counterattacking [10].
The war ended with a ceasefire after about three weeks. In Israel, the Agranat Commission investigated the intelligence failure. In Egypt, the crossing of the canal became a source of national pride. The war led eventually to negotiations and the Egypt-Israel peace treaty of 1979, showing how a surprise attack could reshape diplomacy as well as battle lines.
Conclusion
The ten attacks above share a pattern. The attackers did something the defenders thought unlikely, whether in timing, place or method. Very often, warnings existed but were outweighed by fixed assumptions, from Stalin's disbelief in 1941 to Israel's intelligence concept in 1973.
Surprise rarely wins a war by itself. Barbarossa, Pearl Harbor and Inchon were followed by long, costly campaigns that went in unexpected directions. But surprise can change the shape of a conflict, and its history is a reminder that the most dangerous assumption is that the other side will act as expected.
- ^ [1] Accounts of the 1667 raid and the Treaty of Breda. Wikipedia: Raid on the Medway Wikipedia: Second Anglo-Dutch War
- ^ [2] Accounts of Washington's crossing and the Battle of Trenton. Wikipedia: Battle of Trenton Wikipedia: Washington's crossing of the Delaware
- ^ [3] Accounts of the 1904 attack and the Russo-Japanese War. Wikipedia: Battle of Port Arthur Wikipedia: Russo-Japanese War
- ^ [4] Accounts of the Taranto raid and its influence. Wikipedia: Battle of Taranto Wikipedia: Fairey Swordfish
- ^ [5] Accounts of the 1940 campaign through the Ardennes. Wikipedia: Battle of Sedan (1940) Wikipedia: Battle of France
- ^ [6] Accounts of the 1941 invasion and Soviet unpreparedness. Wikipedia: Operation Barbarossa Wikipedia: Eastern Front
- ^ [7] Accounts of the Pearl Harbor attack and the intelligence failures. Wikipedia: Attack on Pearl Harbor Wikipedia: Pearl Harbor advance-knowledge debate
- ^ [8] Accounts of the Inchon landing. Wikipedia: Battle of Inchon Wikipedia: Korean War
- ^ [9] Accounts of Operation Focus and the Six-Day War. Wikipedia: Operation Focus Wikipedia: Six-Day War
- ^ [10] Accounts of the 1973 war and the Agranat Commission. Wikipedia: Yom Kippur War Wikipedia: Agranat Commission
Discussion
Log in with