Constitutions usually set out governments and rights, but some go further, protecting forests, nature, coca leaves and even the dignity of plants. A national constitution is usually thought of as a dry legal document. It sets out how a government is organized, how leaders are chosen and what rights citizens have. Most constitutions share many of the same features, often borrowed from one another.
Yet some constitutions contain provisions that are unusual, surprising or even unique. They reflect the particular history, culture and concerns of the countries that wrote them, and they show how constitutions can be used to express national values as well as to organize power.
Some of these provisions grew out of painful experiences, such as war or dictatorship. Others reflect environmental concerns, cultural traditions or economic debates that seemed urgent at the time they were written.
Not every unusual provision works as intended. Some are difficult to enforce, and others have been changed or removed after critics argued that they did not belong in a constitution at all. Courts and governments often struggle to translate broad principles into specific rules.
The ten provisions below come from constitutions around the world, in Europe, Asia and Latin America. Some are in force today, while one was removed after it proved impractical and another survived an attempt to change it.
Together, they show the wide variety of ways in which nations have chosen to define themselves in their highest law.
They also show that constitutions are living documents. Many of the provisions below were added through amendments long after the original texts were written, and debates about whether to keep or change them continue in several countries.
Comparing constitutions can also reveal shared trends. Environmental rights, for example, have become much more common in constitutions written or revised since the 1970s.
The length of constitutions also varies enormously. The Constitution of the United States, one of the oldest still in use, is short and has been amended only twenty-seven times. India's constitution, by contrast, is among the longest in the world, with hundreds of articles and many schedules covering everything from languages to the powers of local councils. Longer constitutions tend to include more detailed and unusual provisions, because they try to settle more questions in advance.
Key Facts
| # | Provision | Country | Adopted |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Right of resistance | Germany | 1968 |
| 2 | Minimum forest cover | Bhutan | 2008 |
| 3 | Rights of nature | Ecuador | 2008 |
| 4 | Article 9 | Japan | 1947 |
| 5 | Abolition of the military | Costa Rica | 1949 |
| 6 | Protection of coca | Bolivia | 2009 |
| 7 | Dignity of creatures | Switzerland | 1992 |
| 8 | Interest rate limit | Brazil | 1988 to 2003 |
| 9 | Right to water | Slovenia | 2016 |
| 10 | Article 41.2 | Ireland | 1937 to present |
1. The Right to Resist
Article 20 of Germany's Basic Law sets out the basic principles of the state, including democracy, federalism and the rule of law. In 1968, a fourth paragraph was added, giving all Germans the right to resist anyone seeking to abolish this constitutional order, if no other remedy is available [1].
The provision reflects Germany's experience under the Nazi dictatorship, when democratic institutions were destroyed. It is intended as a last resort to defend democracy, not as a general right to disobey laws [1].
Related: Top 10 Unusual Provisions in National Constitutions
The right of resistance has rarely been tested in court, and legal scholars debate how it would apply in practice. Its presence nonetheless signals the importance Germany places on protecting its democratic order.
2. Forests Forever
Bhutan's constitution, adopted in 2008 when the country became a constitutional monarchy, contains an unusual environmental provision. It requires that at least sixty percent of the country's total land be maintained under forest cover for all time [2].
The constitution also directs the state to pursue conditions that will enable the pursuit of Gross National Happiness, a philosophy that emphasizes well-being, culture and the environment alongside economic growth [2].
Bhutan's forests are an important part of its identity and economy, and the country is often described as carbon negative, absorbing more carbon dioxide than it emits. The constitutional requirement helps protect this status.
3. Rights for Nature Itself
In 2008, Ecuador became the first country to recognize the rights of nature in its constitution. The document states that nature, or Pachamama, has the right to exist, persist and regenerate its life cycles [3].
The provision allows people to bring legal cases on behalf of nature, for example to protect rivers, forests or ecosystems from damage. Ecuadorian courts have used it in several cases, including decisions protecting rivers and forests from harmful projects [3].
The idea has inspired legal movements in other countries, and some courts and legislatures have recognized rights for specific rivers or ecosystems. Critics argue that the rights can be hard to balance with economic development.
4. Renouncing War
After the Second World War, Japan adopted a new constitution that came into force in 1947. Its Article 9 states that the Japanese people forever renounce war as a sovereign right of the nation and the threat or use of force as a means of settling international disputes [4].
The article also states that land, sea and air forces will never be maintained. Despite this, Japan has developed the Self-Defense Forces, which the government argues are permitted for defense [4].
The interpretation of Article 9 has been debated for decades, and some politicians have sought to amend it. The article has never been formally changed, making it one of the most famous peace clauses in any constitution.
Related: Top 10 Most Bizarre Phobias: Strange Fears That Exist
5. No Army
After a brief civil war in 1948, Costa Rica abolished its army. The decision was confirmed in Article 12 of its 1949 constitution, which states that the army as a permanent institution is abolished [5].
The country maintains police forces for public security, but it does not have a standing military. The money saved was invested in education, health and other public services [5].
Costa Rica's lack of an army has become an important part of its national identity. The country is often cited as an example of how a nation can maintain security and stability without a military.
6. The Sacred Leaf
Bolivia's constitution, adopted in 2009, includes a provision on the coca leaf. It states that the state protects native and ancestral coca as cultural heritage and a renewable natural resource, and that coca in its natural state is not a narcotic [6].
The coca leaf has been chewed and used in tea for thousands of years in the Andes, where it plays an important cultural and religious role. It is also the raw material for cocaine, which is why its cultivation is controlled internationally [6].
The provision reflects tensions between Bolivia's traditions and international drug control treaties. Bolivia has sought international recognition for the traditional chewing of coca leaves.
7. The Dignity of Living Things
The Swiss constitution contains a provision on gene technology that requires the government to take into account the dignity of living beings when making rules on the use of genetic material from animals, plants and other organisms [7].
The concept was added to the constitution in 1992 and has been carried into the current constitution. It has led to discussions about what dignity means for plants as well as animals [7].
Related: Top 10 Oldest Buildings in the World
In 2008, a Swiss ethics committee published a report on the dignity of plants, which attracted international attention. The provision shows how a constitution can address new technologies and ethical questions.
8. A Cap on Interest Rates
Brazil's constitution of 1988 included a provision limiting real interest rates to twelve percent per year. The rule was intended to protect borrowers from excessive interest charges [8].
The provision proved difficult to apply. Courts ruled that it required further legislation to take effect, and in practice it was never enforced. Economists criticized it as unrealistic, especially at a time of high inflation [8].
The interest rate cap was removed from the constitution by an amendment in 2003. It is often cited as an example of a provision that may not belong in a constitution.
9. A Right to Drinking Water
In 2016, Slovenia amended its constitution to include the right to drinkable water. The amendment states that everyone has the right to drinking water and that water resources are a public good managed by the state [9].
The amendment also states that water resources serve first and foremost to supply the population with drinking water and are not a market commodity. This was intended to prevent the privatization of water supplies [9].
Slovenia was one of the first countries in the European Union to put the right to water into its constitution. The move reflected growing concern about access to clean water around the world.
10. Women in the Home
Ireland's constitution of 1937 includes a provision recognizing that by her life within the home, woman gives to the state a support without which the common good cannot be achieved. It adds that the state shall endeavor to ensure that mothers are not obliged to work outside the home because of economic necessity [10].
Many critics have argued that the language is outdated and sexist. In March 2024, the Irish government held referendums to change the provision and the constitution's definition of family [10].
Related: 10 Sikh Gurus: The Pillars of Sikhism Who Shaped Faith, Equality, Courage, and Humanity
Both proposals were rejected by voters, partly because some felt the new wording was unclear. The provision therefore remains in the constitution, and debate about how to update it continues.
Conclusion
These unusual constitutional provisions show how national charters can reflect history, culture and values. They range from protecting forests and nature to renouncing war and abolishing armies.
Some provisions have been highly influential, inspiring legal changes in other countries. Others have proved difficult to apply and have been changed or removed.
Constitutions are often seen as permanent, but they evolve over time. Amendments and court rulings can reshape their meaning, and new provisions can be added to address new challenges.
Studying unusual provisions helps us understand what different nations consider most important. A constitution, after all, is not only a set of rules but also a statement of identity.
As societies face new challenges, from climate change to new technologies, it is likely that even more creative provisions will be written into constitutions in the years ahead.
Changing a constitution is usually deliberately difficult. Many countries require special majorities in parliament, approval by regional governments or a national referendum. These hurdles are meant to protect fundamental rules from short-term political pressure, but they also mean that outdated or unusual provisions can remain in place for decades, as the cases of Japan and Ireland show.
Reading them side by side is a reminder that there is no single right way to write the highest law of a nation, and that every constitution tells a story about the people it serves.
- ^ [1] Accounts of the right of resistance. Wikipedia: right of resistance Wikipedia: Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany
- ^ [2] Accounts of Bhutan's constitution. Wikipedia: Constitution of Bhutan Wikipedia: Gross National Happiness
- ^ [3] Accounts of the rights of nature. Wikipedia: Rights of nature in Ecuador Wikipedia: Constitution of Ecuador
- ^ [4] Accounts of Article 9. Wikipedia: Article 9 of the Japanese Constitution Wikipedia: Japan Self-Defense Forces
- ^ [5] Accounts of Costa Rica. Wikipedia: Military of Costa Rica Wikipedia: Costa Rican Civil War
- ^ [6] Accounts of Bolivia and coca. Wikipedia: Constitution of Bolivia Wikipedia: coca leaf
- ^ [7] Accounts of the Swiss constitution. Wikipedia: Federal Constitution of the Swiss Confederation Wikipedia: plant rights
- ^ [8] Accounts of Brazil's constitution. Wikipedia: Constitution of Brazil Wikipedia: usury
- ^ [9] Accounts of Slovenia and water. Wikipedia: Constitution of Slovenia Wikipedia: right to water
- ^ [10] Accounts of Ireland's Article 41.2. Wikipedia: Thirty-ninth Amendment of the Constitution of Ireland Wikipedia: Fortieth Amendment of the Constitution Bill 2023
Discussion
Log in with