The Sultana, Peshtigo, the Eastland and Texas City each killed hundreds or more, yet few Americans know them. Ten overlooked disasters from US history. Some American disasters, such as the sinking of the Titanic or the San Francisco earthquake, are widely remembered. Others that killed hundreds or even thousands of people have largely faded from public memory.
Timing often played a role. Some catastrophes coincided with bigger news, such as the end of the Civil War or the Great Chicago Fire. Others struck people with little political power, including enslaved people, Black farmworkers and immigrant laborers, whose deaths received less attention than they deserved.
Many of these tragedies nonetheless led to lasting changes in fire codes, building safety, ship design and weather forecasting. Their effects can still be seen in theaters, factories and harbors today.
Death tolls for some of these events are uncertain because records were incomplete. The figures below are the commonly cited estimates.
Key Facts
| # | Disaster | Place and date | Deaths |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sultana explosion | Mississippi River near Memphis, April 1865 | Around 1,100 or more |
| 2 | Peshtigo fire | Wisconsin, October 1871 | Estimated 1,200 to 2,400 |
| 3 | Eastland disaster | Chicago River, July 1915 | 844 |
| 4 | Texas City disaster | Texas City, Texas, April 1947 | At least 581 |
| 5 | Okeechobee hurricane | South Florida, September 1928 | At least 2,500 |
| 6 | Iroquois Theatre fire | Chicago, December 1903 | At least 602 |
| 7 | Port Chicago disaster | California, July 1944 | 320 |
| 8 | Schoolhouse Blizzard | Great Plains, January 1888 | Around 235 |
| 9 | Knickerbocker storm | Washington, DC, January 1922 | 98 |
| 10 | Great Natchez Tornado | Natchez, Mississippi, May 1840 | At least 317 |
1. An Overloaded Steamboat
In April 1865, the steamboat Sultana was carrying Union soldiers home from the Civil War, many of them recently released from Confederate prison camps. Built to carry about 376 passengers, it was packed with more than 2,000 people [1].
On April 27, a few hours after leaving Memphis, Tennessee, its boilers exploded. Fire spread across the wooden vessel, and many passengers drowned in the cold, flooded river. A boiler had been hastily repaired days earlier in Vicksburg rather than properly replaced [1].
The Sultana remains the deadliest maritime disaster in US history. But it happened less than two weeks after the assassination of Abraham Lincoln, and newspapers gave it little attention. Investigations later suggested that army officers had overloaded the boat, possibly in return for payments from the owners, who received a fee for each soldier carried. No one was ever successfully prosecuted. The wreck now lies buried under farmland, because the river has shifted course since 1865.
2. A Firestorm Overshadowed by Chicago
On October 8, 1871, a huge wildfire swept through forests and towns in northeastern Wisconsin and nearby parts of Michigan. Dry conditions and strong winds turned scattered fires into a firestorm that destroyed the town of Peshtigo [2].
Survivors described a wall of flame and whirlwinds of fire. Many people sought shelter in the Peshtigo River, while others died in the open. The fire burned more than a million acres of land [2].
It is the deadliest wildfire in recorded US history. Yet it began on the same night as the Great Chicago Fire, which received most of the national attention. Several hundred unidentified victims were buried in a mass grave in Peshtigo, which is marked today by a memorial. During World War II, military planners reportedly studied the Peshtigo fire to understand how firestorms form, as they considered incendiary bombing.
Related: History of Bombay: From Seven Islands to Mumbai
3. A Ship That Rolled Over at the Dock
On July 24, 1915, thousands of workers from the Western Electric Company and their families boarded the passenger ship Eastland for a company picnic. The ship was still tied to its dock on the Chicago River [3].
The Eastland, which was known to be unstable, began to list and then rolled onto its side in water only about 20 feet deep. Many passengers were trapped below deck. In total, 844 passengers and crew died, including entire families [3].
The death toll was higher than that of any other single shipwreck on the Great Lakes. Ironically, lifeboats added after the Titanic disaster may have made the ship more top-heavy. Many of the victims were young immigrant workers and their children. The ship was later raised and converted into a US Navy training vessel, the USS Wilmette, which served on Lake Michigan until after World War II.
4. The Port That Exploded
On April 16, 1947, a fire broke out aboard the French ship Grandcamp in the port of Texas City. The ship was carrying about 2,300 tons of ammonium nitrate fertilizer [4].
Crowds gathered to watch as firefighters battled the blaze. Shortly after 9 a.m., the cargo exploded, destroying much of the waterfront and nearby buildings. Nearly all of the city's volunteer firefighters were killed. The next day, a second ship loaded with fertilizer also exploded [4].
The disaster is considered the deadliest industrial accident in US history. It led to the first class action lawsuit against the federal government, although the Supreme Court ruled in 1953 that the government was not liable. Congress later passed legislation to compensate victims. The explosion was so powerful that it was heard many miles away, and two small planes flying overhead were knocked out of the sky. The disaster also shaped later rules for handling ammonium nitrate, a chemical involved in several later explosions around the world.
5. A Hurricane and a Broken Dike
In September 1928, a powerful hurricane crossed Florida. Its winds pushed the water of Lake Okeechobee over a low earthen dike, flooding farming communities around its southern shore [5].
Most of those killed were Black migrant farmworkers, many from the Bahamas. Their bodies were buried in mass graves, and some were burned, while white victims more often received coffins and burials in cemeteries [5].
Related: Ukraine: A Historical Overview of Eastern Europe's Heartland
The storm also caused major damage in Puerto Rico and the Caribbean. In its aftermath, the government built a much larger dike, later named the Herbert Hoover Dike. The novelist Zora Neale Hurston described the disaster in Their Eyes Were Watching God. The storm reached Category 5 strength, the highest on the modern hurricane scale, as it struck Puerto Rico. A mass grave for many of the Black victims in West Palm Beach was later recognized with a historical marker, after decades of neglect.
6. The Fireproof Theater That Burned
The Iroquois Theatre in Chicago opened in November 1903 and was advertised as absolutely fireproof. On December 30, during a holiday matinee crowded with children, a stage light ignited a curtain [6].
Fire spread quickly, and the asbestos safety curtain failed to come down fully. Many exits were locked, concealed or difficult to open, and doors opened inward. Hundreds of people were crushed or killed by smoke and flames [6].
It remains the deadliest single-building fire in US history. The tragedy led to new fire codes nationwide, including requirements that exit doors open outward and the development of panic bars. The play on stage that day was the musical Mr. Bluebeard, starring the comedian Eddie Foy, who tried to calm the audience during the fire. Investigations revealed numerous safety failures, but legal cases against the theater's managers and city officials ended without convictions.
7. An Explosion That Led to a Mutiny Trial
On July 17, 1944, two ships being loaded with munitions exploded at the Port Chicago Naval Magazine near San Francisco Bay. The blast killed 320 people, most of them Black sailors assigned to the dangerous loading work [7].
Weeks later, many surviving sailors refused to return to loading munitions under unsafe conditions. Fifty were convicted of mutiny and sentenced to prison [7].
The case drew attention to segregation and unequal treatment in the Navy and contributed to its desegregation. In 2024, the Navy formally exonerated the fifty convicted sailors. The future Supreme Court justice Thurgood Marshall, then a lawyer for the NAACP, attended the court-martial and criticized the proceedings. The site of the disaster is now the Port Chicago Naval Magazine National Memorial, managed by the National Park Service.
Related: Top 10 Extremes and Records on Planet Earth
8. A Storm That Caught Children on the Way Home
On January 12, 1888, the morning on the Great Plains was unusually mild. Many people went out without heavy coats, and children walked to school [8].
By afternoon, a fierce blizzard with high winds, blinding snow and plunging temperatures swept across Nebraska, the Dakota Territory and nearby areas. Many victims were children caught on their way home from school [8].
The storm became known as the Schoolhouse Blizzard or the Children's Blizzard. It led to criticism of the government's weather forecasting service, which was then run by the Army Signal Corps. Stories of teachers who guided their pupils to safety, sometimes by tying them together with rope, became part of regional folklore, although details of some accounts are uncertain. Many survivors lost fingers, hands or feet to frostbite. In 1890, responsibility for weather forecasting was transferred to a new civilian Weather Bureau.
9. A Theater Roof Under Snow
In late January 1922, a blizzard dropped more than two feet of snow on Washington, DC. On the evening of January 28, the heavy snow on the flat roof of the Knickerbocker Theatre caused it to collapse during a film screening [9].
The roof brought down part of the balcony, and 98 people were killed. Rescue workers searched through the rubble overnight [9].
The disaster led to changes in building codes for snow loads. The storm that caused it is known as the Knickerbocker storm. The theater was only a few years old and was one of the most fashionable in the city. Among the dead was a former member of Congress. The storm's snowfall remains the largest single-storm total officially recorded in Washington, DC, to date.
10. The Deadly Natchez Tornado
On May 7, 1840, a powerful tornado moved along the Mississippi River and struck Natchez, Mississippi. Many victims were on flatboats and other vessels on the river, which were destroyed [10].
Related: Top 10 Famous Shipwrecks That Rewrote History
The official death toll was 317, making it the second-deadliest tornado in US history. The true number may have been higher, because deaths of enslaved people may not have been fully counted [10].
Much of the town was damaged, but because it happened long before modern weather records, the storm is little known outside the region. The tornado struck on a spring afternoon and lasted only a few minutes in the city itself, but it destroyed many houses, churches and riverfront businesses. Records list more deaths than injuries, an unusual pattern that reflects how many victims drowned when their boats were destroyed.
Conclusion
These disasters show how easily major tragedies can fade from memory. Many were overshadowed by other news or affected communities whose stories were not widely told.
Yet many of them led to important changes in safety regulations, building codes, ship design and forecasting that protect people today.
Museums, memorials and historians have worked to keep some of these stories alive. In Chicago, Florida and elsewhere, memorials now mark several of these disasters.
Remembering them honors the victims and helps explain why many modern safety rules exist.
- ^ [1] Accounts of the Sultana. Wikipedia: Sultana (steamboat) Wikipedia: Andersonville Prison
- ^ [2] Accounts of the Peshtigo fire. Wikipedia: Peshtigo fire Wikipedia: Great Chicago Fire
- ^ [3] Accounts of the Eastland. Wikipedia: Eastland disaster Wikipedia: Western Electric
- ^ [4] Accounts of Texas City. Wikipedia: Texas City disaster Wikipedia: ammonium nitrate
- ^ [5] Accounts of the Okeechobee hurricane. Wikipedia: 1928 Okeechobee hurricane Wikipedia: Herbert Hoover Dike
- ^ [6] Accounts of the Iroquois Theatre. Wikipedia: Iroquois Theatre fire Wikipedia: crash bar
- ^ [7] Accounts of Port Chicago. Wikipedia: Port Chicago disaster Wikipedia: Port Chicago 50
- ^ [8] Accounts of the Schoolhouse Blizzard. Wikipedia: Schoolhouse Blizzard Wikipedia: Great Plains
- ^ [9] Accounts of the Knickerbocker storm. Wikipedia: Knickerbocker storm Wikipedia: Knickerbocker Theatre
- ^ [10] Accounts of the Natchez tornado. Wikipedia: Great Natchez Tornado Wikipedia: Natchez, Mississippi
Discussion
Log in with