Stonewall Jackson, the Battle of Barking Creek, a fogbound landing on an empty island and a downed Black Hawk: ten notable friendly fire incidents. Friendly fire, also called fratricide, occurs when soldiers attack their own side or allies by mistake. It has happened in almost every war, caused by poor visibility, confusion, faulty communications and the chaos of combat.
As weapons have become more powerful and able to strike from greater distances, the risks have grown. Pilots and gunners may have only seconds to decide whether a target is friend or foe, often relying on radar, radio or brief glimpses.
Friendly fire incidents can have outsized effects. They have killed famous commanders, damaged relations between allies and prompted major changes in technology, training and procedures.
The ten incidents below span more than two centuries. Most are well documented; where accounts are disputed or exaggerated, that is noted.
Key Facts
| # | Incident | Date | Consequences |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Battle of Karansebes | September 1788 | A rout of uncertain scale |
| 2 | Stonewall Jackson | May 1863 | Loss of a key Confederate commander |
| 3 | Battle of Barking Creek | September 1939 | The first British fighter pilot killed in the war |
| 4 | Sicily airborne disaster | July 1943 | Heavy losses among paratroopers |
| 5 | Kiska landing | August 1943 | Casualties on an abandoned island |
| 6 | Operation Cobra | July 1944 | A general among the dead |
| 7 | Black Hawk shootdown | April 1994 | Twenty-six killed |
| 8 | Gulf War friendly fire | 1991 | Changes in combat identification |
| 9 | Patriot friendly fire | 2003 | Lessons in automated systems |
| 10 | Pat Tillman | April 2004 | A national controversy |
1. An Army Fighting Itself
During a war between Austria and the Ottoman Empire, Austrian troops were camped near Karansebes, in what is now Romania. According to a popular account, cavalry soldiers who had bought alcohol clashed with infantry, shots were fired and someone shouted that the Turks were coming [1].
The story says that panic spread through the army in the dark, and soldiers fired on one another as they fled. Some versions claim thousands of deaths [1].
Historians consider these figures greatly exaggerated. The most dramatic accounts were written decades later, and contemporary reports describe a chaotic retreat with far smaller losses. The incident remains a famous but uncertain example of confusion in war. The Austrian army was commanded in person by Emperor Joseph II, who was reportedly swept along in the retreat. The army regrouped, and the war continued until 1791, ending with the Treaty of Sistova. Whatever its true scale, the episode is often cited in discussions of how panic can spread through large armies at night.
2. A General Shot by His Own Men
On the night of May 2, 1863, during the Battle of Chancellorsville in Virginia, the Confederate General Thomas Stonewall Jackson rode out with his staff to scout ahead of his lines [2].
As they returned in the darkness, soldiers of a North Carolina regiment mistook them for Union cavalry and opened fire. Jackson was hit by three bullets, and his left arm had to be amputated [2].
He died of pneumonia eight days later. General Robert E. Lee reportedly said that Jackson had lost his left arm but that he had lost his right. Jackson's death was a major blow to the Confederacy. Jackson's amputated arm was buried separately in a family cemetery near the battlefield, where a small marker still identifies the grave. Jackson had earned his nickname at the First Battle of Bull Run in 1861.
Related: Stalingrad Was a Major Turning Point
3. A Battle Against Nobody
On September 6, 1939, just three days after Britain declared war on Germany, a radar station in Essex reported aircraft approaching. Royal Air Force fighters were scrambled to intercept them [3].
The aircraft were in fact British. In the confusion, Spitfires of one squadron attacked Hurricanes of another, shooting down two. Pilot Officer Montague Hulton-Harrop was killed, becoming the first British fighter pilot to die in the war [3].
The incident revealed problems with radar plotting and aircraft identification. Improvements made afterward helped the RAF during the Battle of Britain in 1940. The two Spitfire pilots who fired the fatal shots were court-martialed and acquitted. One of them, John Freeborn, went on to become a successful fighter pilot in the Battle of Britain. The radar station had reportedly displayed aircraft behind it as if they were approaching from the sea.
4. Paratroopers Shot Down by Their Own Fleet
On the night of July 11, 1943, during the Allied invasion of Sicily, transport planes carried American paratroopers to reinforce troops on the island. Their route passed over the Allied fleet shortly after a German air attack [4].
Nervous naval and ground gunners opened fire on the transports, believing them to be enemy aircraft. Twenty-three planes were shot down and many more were damaged [4].
Hundreds of paratroopers and aircrew were killed or wounded. The disaster led to changes in how airborne operations were coordinated with naval and ground forces. The paratroopers belonged to the 504th Parachute Infantry Regiment of the 82nd Airborne Division. Some planes that survived the barrage returned to North Africa riddled with bullet holes. Allied commanders ordered investigations, which found that warnings about the flight had not reached all units.
5. Fighting in the Fog
In August 1943, more than 34,000 American and Canadian troops landed on Kiska, an island in Alaska's Aleutian chain that had been occupied by Japan. Unknown to them, the Japanese garrison had already evacuated under the cover of fog [5].
In the thick fog, Allied soldiers mistook one another for the enemy and opened fire. Together with booby traps and mines, the confusion killed more than thirty soldiers and wounded many more [5].
Related: Top 10 Most Lopsided Battles in History
A US Navy destroyer also struck a mine near the island, killing about seventy sailors. The operation became a notorious example of the costs of poor intelligence and visibility. The Japanese had removed about 5,000 troops from Kiska in a daring operation under fog in late July, without being detected by Allied ships patrolling the area. The landing force found only a few abandoned dogs. The Aleutian campaign was the only land fighting in North America during World War II.
6. Bombs That Fell Short
In July 1944, Allied commanders planned a massive bombing to break through German lines in Normandy, an operation called Cobra. Heavy bombers were to strike German positions just beyond the American front line [6].
On July 24 and 25, many bombs fell short, hitting American troops. More than a hundred American soldiers were killed and hundreds wounded. Among the dead was Lieutenant General Lesley McNair, one of the highest-ranking American officers killed in the war [6].
Despite the losses, the operation succeeded in breaking through German defenses and led to the Allied breakout from Normandy. The incident prompted debate over the bombers' approach route. Ground commanders had asked for the bombers to fly parallel to the front line, but the air commanders chose a perpendicular route to reduce exposure to anti-aircraft fire, increasing the risk of bombs falling short. The breakthrough came over the following days as American armored divisions pushed through the gap.
7. Helicopters Downed Over Iraq
On April 14, 1994, two US Air Force F-15 fighters patrolling the no-fly zone over northern Iraq shot down two US Army Black Hawk helicopters, mistaking them for Iraqi helicopters [7].
All 26 people on board were killed, including American, British, French and Turkish personnel and Kurdish civilians working with a humanitarian mission [7].
Investigations found failures in communication, identification and coordination, including problems involving the airborne warning aircraft overseeing the area. The incident led to changes in procedures for identifying aircraft. The F-15 pilots made a brief visual pass but misidentified the helicopters as Soviet-made Mi-24 Hind helicopters used by Iraq. Electronic identification signals failed to confirm the Black Hawks as friendly, partly because of mismatched codes. One officer was court-martialed and acquitted, a result that drew criticism from victims' families.
Related: Top 10 Inventions That Changed Warfare: Chariots to Drones
8. A Quarter of the Deaths
During the 1991 Gulf War, friendly fire accounted for a significant share of American combat deaths. Around 35 of about 146 US battle deaths were caused by friendly fire [8].
In one incident, on February 26, 1991, two American A-10 attack aircraft fired on British armored vehicles, killing nine British soldiers. The incident caused tension between the allies and led to inquiries [8].
These incidents prompted efforts to develop better systems for identifying friendly forces, including markers on vehicles and electronic tracking systems. In the 1991 Gulf War, coalition forces fought largely at night and in poor visibility caused by smoke from burning oil wells, while advanced weapons allowed them to engage targets at long range. A British inquest in 1992 returned a verdict of unlawful killing, and the American pilots did not give evidence.
9. Missiles Against Allied Jets
On March 23, 2003, during the invasion of Iraq, an American Patriot missile battery shot down a British Tornado aircraft returning from a mission, killing both crew members [9].
On April 2, another Patriot missile shot down an American F/A-18 fighter, killing its pilot. Investigations found problems with how the Patriot system classified aircraft and with identification systems [9].
The incidents raised questions about the reliance on automated systems in combat. Changes were made to procedures and to the Patriot system itself. The two British airmen were Flight Lieutenants Kevin Main and David Williams. A board of inquiry found that the Tornado's identification system may not have been working properly and that the Patriot's software had misclassified the aircraft as a missile.
10. A Famous Soldier and a Cover-Up
Pat Tillman was an American football player who left a lucrative contract with the Arizona Cardinals to join the US Army after the September 11 attacks. He served as an Army Ranger in Iraq and Afghanistan [10].
Related: Top 10 Overlooked Events of World War II
On April 22, 2004, Tillman was killed in Afghanistan. The Army initially said that he had died fighting the enemy, and he was awarded the Silver Star [10].
Weeks later, it emerged that he had been killed by fire from his own unit. His family and members of Congress criticized the Army for misleading the public, and several officers were later disciplined. Tillman's story had been widely publicized, and his memorial service was broadcast nationally. Congressional hearings in 2007 examined how the Army had handled information about his death. A foundation in his name provides scholarships to military veterans and their spouses.
Conclusion
Friendly fire incidents show how difficult it is to distinguish friend from foe in the confusion of war. They have claimed the lives of generals, pilots and ordinary soldiers.
Many incidents led to improvements in communication, identification and training, as militaries sought to prevent them from happening again.
Despite these efforts, friendly fire remains a risk in modern warfare, especially in fast-moving operations involving many forces.
Remembering these incidents honors those who died and highlights the importance of careful coordination.
- ^ [1] Accounts of Karansebes. Wikipedia: Battle of Karansebes Wikipedia: Austro-Turkish War
- ^ [2] Accounts of Stonewall Jackson. Wikipedia: Stonewall Jackson Wikipedia: Battle of Chancellorsville
- ^ [3] Accounts of Barking Creek. Wikipedia: Battle of Barking Creek Wikipedia: Chain Home
- ^ [4] Accounts of Sicily. Wikipedia: Operation Husky Wikipedia: 504th Infantry Regiment
- ^ [5] Accounts of Kiska. Wikipedia: Operation Cottage Wikipedia: Kiska
- ^ [6] Accounts of Operation Cobra. Wikipedia: Operation Cobra Wikipedia: Lesley J. McNair
- ^ [7] Accounts of the Black Hawk shootdown. Wikipedia: 1994 Black Hawk shootdown incident Wikipedia: Operation Provide Comfort
- ^ [8] Accounts of the Gulf War. Wikipedia: Gulf War Wikipedia: Friendly fire
- ^ [9] Accounts of Patriot incidents. Wikipedia: MIM-104 Patriot Wikipedia: Panavia Tornado
- ^ [10] Accounts of Pat Tillman. Wikipedia: Pat Tillman Wikipedia: List of friendly fire incidents
Discussion
Log in with