Psychology shows our tastes are oddly shaped: we prefer what is familiar, value what we build and own, judge wine by price and even pick shocks over boredom. Most people believe they know what they like and why. We choose foods, products, music and even partners based on what seem like clear personal tastes. But decades of research in psychology and behavioral economics have shown that preferences are shaped by surprising and often hidden influences.
Familiarity, ownership, effort, price, the order in which choices are presented and the way an experience ends can all change what people prefer. Many of these effects operate without people noticing them, and people often give confident explanations for choices that were actually driven by something else.
The ten findings below are the mere exposure effect, the IKEA effect, choice overload, the decoy effect, the endowment effect, the name letter effect, the appeal of average faces, the peak-end rule, the preference for electric shocks over sitting alone with one's thoughts and the influence of price on the taste of wine.
Psychology has gone through a period of intense scrutiny, often called the replication crisis, in which some famous findings failed to hold up when tested again. Where a finding has been challenged or has produced mixed results in later studies, that is noted.
These findings matter beyond the laboratory. Businesses use them in marketing and product design, governments use them in policy, and individuals can use them to make better decisions by understanding the forces that shape their own choices.
They also offer a humbling lesson. Our preferences are not always as independent or rational as we think, and recognizing that can make us more thoughtful about the choices we make every day.
Key Facts
| # | Finding | Key study | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mere exposure effect | Robert Zajonc, 1968 | People tend to like things more simply because they have seen them before |
| 2 | IKEA effect | Michael Norton, Daniel Mochon and Dan Ariely, 2011 | People value things more when they made them themselves |
| 3 | Choice overload | Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper, 2000 | More choice can sometimes reduce buying and satisfaction |
| 4 | Decoy effect | Joel Huber and colleagues, 1982 | Adding a worse option can change what people choose |
| 5 | Endowment effect | Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler, 1990 | People demand more to give something up than they would pay to get it |
| 6 | Name letter effect | Jozef Nuttin, 1985 | People prefer the letters in their own names |
| 7 | Averageness and attractiveness | Judith Langlois and Lori Roggman, 1990 | Composite faces are often rated as more attractive |
| 8 | Peak-end rule | Daniel Kahneman and colleagues, 1990s | People judge experiences by their most intense moment and their end |
| 9 | Thinking alone | Timothy Wilson and colleagues, 2014 | Many people dislike sitting alone with their thoughts |
| 10 | Wine pricing | Hilke Plassmann and colleagues, 2008 | People enjoy wine more when they think it costs more |
1. Familiar Means Likable
In 1968, the psychologist Robert Zajonc published research showing that people tend to develop a preference for things simply because they have been exposed to them repeatedly. In his experiments, people rated unfamiliar words, symbols and faces more positively the more often they had seen them [1].
Later studies found the effect even when people were shown images so briefly that they could not consciously recognize them. Familiarity seemed to create a feeling of ease that people interpreted as liking [1].
The mere exposure effect helps explain why songs often grow on listeners after several plays and why advertisers repeat their messages. It has limits, however; too much exposure can lead to boredom, and the effect is weaker for things people already dislike.
2. Loving What We Build
In a study published in 2011, the researchers Michael Norton, Daniel Mochon and Dan Ariely asked people to assemble simple IKEA storage boxes, fold origami or build Lego sets. Participants were then asked how much they would pay for their creations [2].
Related: Top 10 Psychological Facts About Human Behavior
People who had built the items valued them much more highly than identical items built by others, and often almost as highly as items made by experts. The researchers called this the IKEA effect, after the furniture company famous for flat-pack products that customers assemble themselves [2].
The effect only worked when people completed the task. When they failed to finish or later dismantled what they built, the extra value disappeared. Effort, it seems, creates attachment, but only when it leads to success.
3. Too Many Options
In a famous study published in 2000, the psychologists Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper set up a tasting booth for jams in a grocery store. On some days, the booth offered 24 flavors; on others, it offered only six [3].
The larger display attracted more visitors, but people who saw the smaller selection were far more likely to buy a jar. The researchers suggested that too many options can make decisions harder and lead people to choose nothing at all [3].
The study became one of the best known in behavioral science. However, later research has produced mixed results, and a large analysis of many studies found that choice overload appears only under certain conditions, such as when options are complex or hard to compare.
4. The Option Nobody Wants
The decoy effect, also called asymmetric dominance, was described by Joel Huber, John Payne and Christopher Puto in 1982. They found that adding a third option that is clearly worse than one of the existing choices can make that choice more attractive [4].
A widely cited example involves magazine subscriptions. When people were offered an online subscription, a print subscription at a higher price and a combined print and online subscription at the same price as print alone, most chose the combined option. Without the print-only decoy, many more chose the cheaper online option [4].
The effect shows that people often judge options by comparing them to each other rather than by their absolute value. Businesses frequently use decoy pricing in menus, product lines and subscription plans.
Related: Top 10 Why Introverts Are Attractive
5. Valuing What We Own
In experiments published in 1990, Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler gave some participants coffee mugs and asked them how much they would sell them for. Other participants were asked how much they would pay for the same mugs [5].
The owners consistently asked for about twice as much as the buyers were willing to pay. Simply owning the mug for a few minutes made people value it more. This became known as the endowment effect [5].
The finding is linked to loss aversion, the idea that losses feel more painful than equivalent gains feel good. It helps explain why people hold on to possessions, investments and even ideas longer than might be rational. Kahneman and Thaler both later received Nobel Prizes for their work.
6. Liking the Letters in Our Names
In 1985, the Belgian psychologist Jozef Nuttin reported that people tend to prefer the letters that appear in their own names, especially their initials, over other letters of the alphabet. The effect appeared across many languages [6].
Researchers have since found that people also tend to rate numbers related to their birthdays more favorably. The effect is thought to reflect a general tendency to feel positively about things associated with ourselves [6].
Some researchers went further, claiming that people were more likely to choose careers or places to live that resembled their names. Those bolder claims have been strongly disputed, but the basic preference for one's own letters has been widely replicated.
7. Average Faces Look Good
In 1990, the psychologists Judith Langlois and Lori Roggman used computers to blend photographs of many faces into composite images. They found that people tended to rate the averaged faces as more attractive than most of the individual faces that made them up [7].
The more faces that were blended together, the more attractive the composite was generally rated. Researchers have suggested that average faces may look familiar, healthy and easy for the brain to process [7].
Related: Top 10 Things People Are Systematically Bad at Predicting
The finding does not mean that only average faces are attractive. Some distinctive features are also rated highly, and preferences vary across individuals and cultures. But the study showed that attractiveness is shaped partly by how the brain processes patterns.
8. How It Ends Matters Most
In a study published in 1993, Daniel Kahneman and colleagues asked volunteers to hold their hands in painfully cold water. In one trial, they held a hand in the water for sixty seconds. In another, they held it in for sixty seconds and then for thirty more seconds while the water was warmed slightly [8].
When asked which trial they would repeat, most chose the longer one, even though it involved more total discomfort. They remembered it as less unpleasant because it ended better [8].
Later research in medical procedures supported the idea that people judge experiences largely by their most intense moment and how they end, rather than by their total duration. The peak-end rule has implications for medicine, customer service and even holidays.
9. Shocks Over Boredom
In a study published in Science in 2014, the psychologist Timothy Wilson and colleagues asked participants to sit alone in a room with nothing to do for between six and fifteen minutes. Many found the experience unpleasant [9].
In one experiment, participants could press a button to give themselves a mild electric shock during the session. Even though they had earlier said they would pay to avoid being shocked, about two thirds of the men and a quarter of the women shocked themselves at least once [9].
The researchers suggested that many people find it difficult to entertain themselves with their own thoughts, especially without practice. The study prompted discussion about boredom, smartphones and the value of quiet reflection.
Related: Top 10 Everyday Situations Game Theory Helps Explain
10. Price Changes Taste
In a study published in 2008, Hilke Plassmann and colleagues gave volunteers samples of wine while scanning their brains. The volunteers were told the price of each wine, but some of the same wines were presented with different prices [10].
Participants reported enjoying the wines more when they believed they were more expensive. Brain scans showed greater activity in an area associated with pleasure, suggesting that the higher price actually changed their experience, not just their reported opinion [10].
Other studies have found that even trained tasters can be influenced by labels and appearance. The research suggests that expectations shape taste, a finding with clear implications for marketing and branding.
Conclusion
These findings show that human preferences are shaped by many factors beyond the qualities of the things themselves. Familiarity, ownership, effort, comparisons, expectations and memory all influence what we like and choose.
They also show the importance of careful science. Some famous findings have been challenged by later research, reminding us that single studies should be treated with caution and that the best evidence comes from many studies over time.
Understanding these effects can help people make better choices. Knowing that price can influence taste or that ownership can inflate value can make it easier to step back and ask whether a preference really reflects what we want.
At the same time, these quirks are part of what makes us human. Preferences that seem irrational may have served useful purposes in the past, and studying them helps us understand the mind more fully.
- ^ [1] Accounts of the mere exposure effect. Wikipedia: mere-exposure effect Wikipedia: Robert Zajonc
- ^ [2] Accounts of the IKEA effect. Wikipedia: IKEA effect Wikipedia: effort justification
- ^ [3] Accounts of choice overload. Wikipedia: overchoice Wikipedia: Sheena Iyengar
- ^ [4] Accounts of the decoy effect. Wikipedia: decoy effect Wikipedia: behavioral economics
- ^ [5] Accounts of the endowment effect. Wikipedia: endowment effect Wikipedia: loss aversion
- ^ [6] Accounts of the name letter effect. Wikipedia: name-letter effect Wikipedia: implicit egotism
- ^ [7] Accounts of averageness and attractiveness. Wikipedia: averageness Wikipedia: physical attractiveness
- ^ [8] Accounts of the peak-end rule. Wikipedia: peak-end rule Wikipedia: Daniel Kahneman
- ^ [9] Accounts of the thinking-alone study. Wikipedia: boredom Wikipedia: Timothy Wilson
- ^ [10] Accounts of price and taste. Wikipedia: wine tasting Wikipedia: replication crisis
Discussion
Log in with