Some products vanished almost as soon as they arrived, from New Coke and the Edsel to Microsoft's Kin, HP's TouchPad, a fiery phone and a juicer. Launching a new product is one of the riskiest things a company can do. Months or years of research, design and marketing go into a single moment when the product finally reaches customers. Most launches lead to modest success or slow decline. But a few products fail so quickly and so publicly that they become legends.
The reasons vary. Some products misjudged what customers wanted, while others arrived at the wrong price or the wrong time. Some faced fierce competition, and a few had serious safety problems that forced companies to act fast. In several cases, the failure revealed problems in how decisions were made inside the company.
The ten products below are New Coke, the Ford Edsel, Nintendo's Virtual Boy, Microsoft's Kin phones, the HP TouchPad, the HTC First with Facebook Home, the Amazon Fire Phone, the Samsung Galaxy Note 7, the Quibi streaming service and the Juicero juice press. Some disappeared within weeks; others lasted a year or two.
The details here come from company announcements, news coverage and business histories. Sales figures and losses are approximate, as companies do not always report them fully.
Quick failures are not always disasters for the companies involved. Several of the firms below learned valuable lessons and went on to great success. In at least one case, the failure arguably strengthened the company's brand.
These stories are studied in business schools as cautionary tales. They show how hard it is to predict what customers will embrace and how quickly public opinion can turn.
Speed of failure is itself a modern story. In earlier decades, a weak product might linger on shelves for years before quietly disappearing. Today, online reviews, social media and instant sales data mean that companies can see within days whether a launch is working, and investors expect them to act quickly when it is not. That pressure helps explain why several items on this list vanished in a matter of weeks.
Key Facts
| # | Product | Company | How long it lasted |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New Coke | Coca-Cola | About 79 days in 1985 |
| 2 | Ford Edsel | Ford Motor Company | 1957 to 1959 |
| 3 | Virtual Boy | Nintendo | Less than a year on sale |
| 4 | Microsoft Kin | Microsoft | About 48 days in 2010 |
| 5 | HP TouchPad | Hewlett-Packard | About 49 days in 2011 |
| 6 | HTC First | HTC and Facebook | A few months in 2013 |
| 7 | Amazon Fire Phone | Amazon | About a year |
| 8 | Samsung Galaxy Note 7 | Samsung | About two months in 2016 |
| 9 | Quibi | Quibi | About eight months in 2020 |
| 10 | Juicero | Juicero | About a year and a half |
1. A New Formula for an Old Favorite
In April 1985, the Coca-Cola Company announced that it was changing the formula of its flagship drink for the first time in nearly a century. The company had lost market share to Pepsi, and taste tests suggested that many people preferred a sweeter flavor [1].
The reaction was swift and furious. Customers flooded the company with complaints, some stockpiled the old version and protest groups formed. Many people felt that a beloved part of their lives had been taken away, regardless of how the new drink tasted [1].
On July 11, 1985, the company announced that the original formula would return as Coca-Cola Classic. The episode is often described as a marketing disaster, but sales of the returned drink rose, and some observers argued it reminded the public how much they loved the brand.
Related: Top 10 Corporate Blunders That Became Business Lessons
2. A Car That Missed the Market
The Edsel was launched by Ford in September 1957 after years of planning and heavy publicity. It was meant to fill a gap between Ford's cheaper cars and its upscale Mercury brand, and the company invested hundreds of millions of dollars in the project [2].
The car arrived just as a recession hit and buyers were moving toward smaller, more economical vehicles. Its distinctive vertical grille was mocked, and early cars suffered from quality problems. Sales fell far short of expectations [2].
Ford discontinued the Edsel in November 1959. The name became a byword for commercial failure, though surviving Edsels are now prized by collectors.
3. A Red Headache
Nintendo released the Virtual Boy in Japan in July 1995 and in North America in August 1995. Designed by the famous engineer Gunpei Yokoi, it was marketed as a portable three-dimensional gaming system [3].
The device displayed games in red and black only, and players had to look into a headset mounted on a stand. Many users reported eye strain and headaches. The system was neither truly portable nor comfortable, and there were few games available [3].
Sales were poor, and Nintendo stopped selling the Virtual Boy in Japan within months and in North America in 1996. It is often listed among the company's biggest failures, though it has since become a collector's item.
4. Phones for Young Social Media Users
In 2010, Microsoft launched the Kin, a pair of phones aimed at young people who used social networks. The phones were sold through the American carrier Verizon and focused on sharing photos and updates [4].
Despite years of development, the phones arrived with high monthly plan prices and limited features compared to smartphones. Sales were very low. Within about seven weeks of launch, Microsoft announced it was cancelling the Kin in the United States [4].
The failure became a symbol of Microsoft's struggles in mobile phones at the time. Some of the technology and team members were later folded into the company's Windows Phone efforts.
Related: Top 10 Advertising Campaigns That Backfired
5. A Tablet Cancelled in Seven Weeks
Hewlett-Packard launched the TouchPad tablet on July 1, 2011. It ran webOS, an operating system HP had acquired when it bought the phone maker Palm, and was meant to compete with Apple's iPad [5].
Sales were weak. On August 18, 2011, HP announced that it would stop making webOS devices, including the TouchPad. The company then cut the price to 99 dollars to clear stock, which sparked a buying frenzy, with stores selling out in hours [5].
The episode was part of a wider period of strategic changes at HP. The webOS software later found a new life in smart televisions made by another company.
6. A Facebook Phone
In April 2013, the phone maker HTC released the HTC First, the first phone to come with Facebook Home preinstalled. Facebook Home was a software layer that put Facebook's feed and messaging at the center of the phone's screen [6].
The phone received mixed reviews, and sales were poor. Within weeks, the American carrier AT&T reduced its contract price to 99 cents. Reports soon suggested that the phone would be discontinued [6].
Facebook Home itself was not widely adopted on other phones and was gradually abandoned. The experiment showed that people were not eager to have their entire phone experience organized around a single social network.
7. A Phone From an Online Store
Amazon launched the Fire Phone in July 2014. Its features included a three-dimensional effect created with multiple cameras and a tool called Firefly that could identify products and help users buy them on Amazon [7].
The phone was initially priced like premium smartphones, and it was sold exclusively through one carrier in the United States. Reviewers found its unique features less useful than expected, and sales were very weak [7].
Related: Top 25 Interesting Facts About the Solar System
In October 2014, Amazon reported a charge of about 170 million dollars linked largely to unsold Fire Phone inventory. The phone was discontinued in 2015. Lessons from the project reportedly helped Amazon in developing other devices, including its Echo smart speakers.
8. A Phone That Caught Fire
Samsung launched the Galaxy Note 7 in August 2016, and early reviews were very positive. But within weeks, reports emerged of phones overheating and catching fire. Samsung announced a global recall in September and replaced the devices [8].
Some of the replacement phones also caught fire. Airlines and aviation authorities banned the phone from flights. In October 2016, Samsung permanently stopped production and sales of the Note 7 [8].
Investigations later found that problems with batteries from two different suppliers were responsible. Samsung introduced new safety checks for its batteries and continued its Note series, recovering from the crisis.
9. Short Shows for Short Attention Spans
Quibi was a streaming service that offered short episodes, ten minutes or less, designed to be watched on phones. Its founders raised about 1.75 billion dollars from investors and signed deals with famous actors and directors [9].
The service launched in April 2020, just as the pandemic kept many people at home, where they watched content on large screens rather than phones. Quibi also faced criticism for limited features and failed to attract enough subscribers [9].
In October 2020, the company announced it would shut down, and the service ended in December 2020. Its library of shows was later sold to Roku. The quick collapse became one of the most notable failures in the streaming industry.
10. A Juicer You Did Not Need
Juicero launched a Wi-Fi connected juice press in 2016, initially priced at 699 dollars. It squeezed juice from packs of chopped fruit and vegetables sold by subscription. The company had raised more than 100 million dollars from investors [10].
Related: Top 25 Interesting Facts About the Universe
In April 2017, reporters showed that the packs could be squeezed by hand, producing juice almost as quickly as the machine. The story spread widely, and the product became a symbol of overhyped technology [10].
Juicero cut its price and offered refunds, but it shut down in September 2017. Its story is often cited in discussions of startup excess and products that use technology to solve problems that may not exist.
Conclusion
These products show how quickly the market can judge a new idea. Large budgets, famous brands and strong publicity are no guarantee of success, and sometimes they make failure more visible.
They also show the value of listening to customers. Several of these failures came from misjudging what people wanted, how much they would pay or how they would use the product in daily life.
Failures can lead to learning. Companies that survived these setbacks often used the lessons to build better products, and the stories have become valuable case studies for business students and entrepreneurs.
For consumers, these stories are a reminder that the newest product is not always the best one. Waiting to see how a product performs, and reading reviews, can save money and frustration.
Many successful products also began with false starts. Early tablets, smart watches and streaming services struggled before later versions found an audience, which suggests that some quick failures were less about bad ideas than about arriving before customers, technology or prices were ready.
- ^ [1] Accounts of New Coke. Wikipedia: New Coke Wikipedia: The Coca-Cola Company
- ^ [2] Accounts of the Edsel. Wikipedia: Edsel Wikipedia: Ford Motor Company
- ^ [3] Accounts of the Virtual Boy. Wikipedia: Virtual Boy Wikipedia: Gunpei Yokoi
- ^ [4] Accounts of the Microsoft Kin. Wikipedia: Microsoft Kin Wikipedia: Verizon
- ^ [5] Accounts of the HP TouchPad. Wikipedia: HP TouchPad Wikipedia: webOS
- ^ [6] Accounts of the HTC First. Wikipedia: HTC First Wikipedia: HTC
- ^ [7] Accounts of the Fire Phone. Wikipedia: Fire Phone Wikipedia: Amazon Echo
- ^ [8] Accounts of the Galaxy Note 7. Wikipedia: Samsung Galaxy Note 7 Wikipedia: lithium-ion battery
- ^ [9] Accounts of Quibi. Wikipedia: Quibi Wikipedia: Roku
- ^ [10] Accounts of Juicero. Wikipedia: Juicero Wikipedia: Internet of things
Discussion
Log in with