Beyond solid, liquid and gas, physicists have made strange states of matter in labs, from Bose-Einstein condensates to time crystals and superionic ice. School science usually teaches three states of matter: solid, liquid and gas. Sometimes a fourth, plasma, is added. But physicists have discovered, and in many cases created, a long list of more exotic states that behave in ways that seem to defy everyday experience.
Many of these states appear only at extreme conditions. Some exist at temperatures a tiny fraction of a degree above absolute zero, where quantum effects dominate. Others need pressures and temperatures found deep inside giant planets, or the conditions of the universe a few millionths of a second after the Big Bang.
The ten states below are the Bose-Einstein condensate, the fermionic condensate, superfluid helium, the supersolid, the quark-gluon plasma, the time crystal, photonic molecules, the quantum spin liquid, excitonium and superionic ice. Several of them earned Nobel Prizes for the scientists who first made or explained them.
Some of these results are still being studied, and scientists sometimes debate whether a particular experiment truly shows a new state of matter. Where claims are recent or contested, that is noted.
These exotic states are not just curiosities. Studying them helps physicists understand superconductivity, the interiors of planets, the early universe and the foundations of quantum mechanics, and some may eventually lead to new technologies such as quantum computers and ultra-precise sensors.
Key Facts
| # | State of matter | Key feature | First made or reported |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bose-Einstein condensate | Atoms cooled so much they share a single quantum state | 1995 |
| 2 | Fermionic condensate | Fermion atoms paired up to form a condensate | 2003 |
| 3 | Superfluid helium | A liquid that flows without viscosity | 1937 |
| 4 | Supersolid | A material with a rigid structure that also flows without friction | Reported 2017 to 2019 |
| 5 | Quark-gluon plasma | Quarks and gluons freed from protons and neutrons | Evidence reported 2000 and 2005 |
| 6 | Time crystal | A system that repeats in time without absorbing energy | 2016 to 2017 |
| 7 | Photonic molecules | Photons that bind to each other | 2013 |
| 8 | Quantum spin liquid | Magnetic spins that stay disordered even at absolute zero | Signatures reported 2021 |
| 9 | Excitonium | A condensate made from electron and hole pairs | Evidence reported 2017 |
| 10 | Superionic ice | Water that is both solid and liquid | Evidence 2018; structure 2019 |
1. Atoms That Act as One
In the 1920s, the Indian physicist Satyendra Nath Bose and Albert Einstein predicted that if certain particles were cooled close enough to absolute zero, they would collapse into a single quantum state, behaving like one giant atom [1].
For seventy years, the prediction could not be tested. Then, in June 1995, Eric Cornell and Carl Wieman at JILA in Boulder, Colorado, cooled a gas of rubidium atoms to about 170 billionths of a degree above absolute zero and created the first Bose-Einstein condensate. Wolfgang Ketterle at MIT soon made one with sodium atoms [1].
The three physicists shared the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2001. Bose-Einstein condensates are now used to study quantum behavior, and they have even been created in space aboard the International Space Station.
2. Paired Atoms
Bose-Einstein condensates are made from a type of particle called a boson. Another family of particles, fermions, cannot share the same quantum state, so they cannot form a condensate directly. However, fermions can pair up, and the pairs can behave like bosons [2].
In 2003, a team led by Deborah Jin at JILA in Boulder cooled potassium atoms and used magnetic fields to make them pair up, creating the first fermionic condensate. The achievement was widely recognized as a major step in ultracold physics [2].
Related: Top 10 Real Experiments Behind the Idea of Teleportation
Fermionic condensates are closely related to superconductivity, in which electrons pair up and flow without resistance. Studying them helps physicists understand how superconductors work and may help in the search for materials that superconduct at higher temperatures.
3. A Liquid With No Friction
When helium is cooled below about 2.17 degrees above absolute zero, it changes into a strange form called a superfluid. It flows with no viscosity at all, meaning it has no internal friction [3].
Superfluidity in helium was discovered in 1937 by Pyotr Kapitsa in Moscow and, independently, by John Allen and Don Misener in Cambridge. Superfluid helium can creep up the walls of its container and over the edge, pass through tiny pores that block ordinary liquids and form fountains when heated [3].
Kapitsa received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1978, partly for this work. Superfluid helium is used to cool sensitive equipment, including the superconducting magnets of the Large Hadron Collider and some space telescopes.
4. Solid and Fluid at Once
A supersolid is a state of matter that has the ordered structure of a crystal while also flowing like a superfluid. It sounds contradictory, and for decades physicists debated whether it could exist [4].
In 2004, researchers reported evidence of supersolidity in solid helium, but later work showed the effect had another explanation, and the claim was withdrawn. In 2017, teams at MIT and ETH Zurich reported supersolid-like properties in Bose-Einstein condensates using lasers [4].
In 2019, groups in Stuttgart, Florence and Innsbruck created supersolid states using gases of magnetic atoms such as dysprosium and erbium. Researchers continue to study these states to understand how order and superfluidity can coexist.
5. The Soup of the Early Universe
Protons and neutrons are made of smaller particles called quarks, held together by particles called gluons. Under normal conditions, quarks are never found alone. But at extremely high temperatures, protons and neutrons melt into a soup of free quarks and gluons [5].
Related: Top 25 Interesting Facts About the Solar System
Physicists believe the universe was filled with this quark-gluon plasma for a few millionths of a second after the Big Bang. In 2000, scientists at CERN announced evidence of a new state of matter in collisions of lead nuclei. In 2005, researchers at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider at Brookhaven National Laboratory reported that the plasma behaved like a nearly perfect liquid [5].
The quark-gluon plasma is the hottest matter ever created in a laboratory, with temperatures of trillions of degrees. Experiments at the Large Hadron Collider continue to study it.
6. A Pattern That Repeats in Time
Ordinary crystals have atoms arranged in a pattern that repeats in space. In 2012, the physicist Frank Wilczek proposed that there might also be systems whose structure repeats in time, which he called time crystals [6].
In 2016 and 2017, two teams created versions of time crystals. One, led by Chris Monroe at the University of Maryland, used a chain of trapped ions. Another, led by Mikhail Lukin at Harvard, used defects in diamond. When pulsed regularly, the systems flipped back and forth at a rhythm different from the pulses, in a stable pattern [6].
Time crystals do not create perpetual motion or violate the laws of thermodynamics. They are a new kind of non-equilibrium matter, and researchers have since created them on quantum computers, including one at Google.
7. Light That Sticks Together
Photons, the particles of light, normally do not interact with each other. Two beams of light can cross without affecting each other at all. That is why light sabers from science fiction seemed impossible [7].
In 2013, a team led by Mikhail Lukin at Harvard and Vladan Vuletic at MIT sent weak light through a cloud of very cold rubidium atoms. The photons came out bound together in pairs, behaving like a molecule. The effect depended on strong interactions between atoms excited into high-energy states [7].
Related: Top 25 Interesting Facts About the Universe
The researchers noted, half jokingly, that the effect resembled light sabers. More seriously, photonic molecules could help in quantum information processing, where controlling single photons is important for future quantum computers and networks.
8. Magnets That Never Settle
In most magnetic materials, electron spins line up in an orderly pattern when cooled. In a quantum spin liquid, they never settle down. Instead, they remain in a constantly fluctuating, entangled state, even at the lowest temperatures [8].
The physicist Philip Anderson proposed the idea in 1973. For decades, researchers searched for materials that might host spin liquids, with several candidate minerals showing promising but debated results [8].
In 2021, a team at Harvard used a programmable quantum simulator made from arrays of atoms held by lasers to observe signatures of a quantum spin liquid, published in Science. Researchers hope spin liquids could one day help build more robust quantum computers.
9. A Condensate of Excitons
When an electron in a material is excited, it leaves behind a hole, a gap that behaves like a positive charge. The electron and hole can attract each other and form a pair called an exciton. In the 1960s, physicists predicted that excitons could condense into a new state of matter, called excitonium [9].
For decades, proof was elusive. In 2017, a team led by Peter Abbamonte at the University of Illinois reported evidence of excitonium in crystals of titanium diselenide, using a new technique to measure electron energy loss [9].
The discovery was described as evidence of a new form of matter that had been predicted for nearly fifty years. Research continues on its properties and on whether excitons might have practical uses in electronics.
Related: Top 10 Mythical Creatures in World Mythology - That Inspired Myths Across Civilizations (unchanged)
10. Ice That Conducts Electricity
Superionic ice is a form of water that exists at enormous pressures and temperatures. In it, the oxygen atoms form a solid crystal lattice, while the hydrogen ions move freely through it like a liquid, allowing it to conduct electricity [10].
Scientists predicted superionic ice in the late 1980s. In 2018, researchers at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory reported evidence of it using laser shocks. In 2019, a team used powerful lasers at the Laboratory for Laser Energetics in Rochester to compress water and determined its crystal structure with X-rays, finding a form now called ice XVIII [10].
Scientists believe superionic ice may make up large parts of the interiors of Uranus and Neptune. It could help explain the unusual magnetic fields of those planets.
Conclusion
These exotic states show that matter is far stranger than the three states taught in school. At extremes of temperature, pressure and energy, particles behave in ways that reveal the deep rules of quantum physics.
Many of these discoveries began as predictions decades before they could be tested. The gap between theory and experiment shows how much patience and new technology are needed to explore the strange corners of nature.
Research in this field continues to move quickly. New states of matter are still being proposed and created, and some of them may one day become as useful as the ordinary materials around us.
For anyone curious to learn more, university physics departments and national laboratories often publish accessible explanations of their latest experiments with exotic matter.
- ^ [1] Accounts of Bose-Einstein condensates. Wikipedia: Bose-Einstein condensate Wikipedia: Wolfgang Ketterle
- ^ [2] Accounts of fermionic condensates. Wikipedia: fermionic condensate Wikipedia: Deborah S. Jin
- ^ [3] Accounts of superfluid helium. Wikipedia: superfluid helium-4 Wikipedia: Pyotr Kapitsa
- ^ [4] Accounts of supersolids. Wikipedia: supersolid Wikipedia: superfluidity
- ^ [5] Accounts of the quark-gluon plasma. Wikipedia: quark-gluon plasma Wikipedia: Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider
- ^ [6] Accounts of time crystals. Wikipedia: time crystal Wikipedia: Frank Wilczek
- ^ [7] Accounts of photonic molecules. Wikipedia: photonic molecule Wikipedia: Rydberg atom
- ^ [8] Accounts of quantum spin liquids. Wikipedia: quantum spin liquid Wikipedia: Philip W. Anderson
- ^ [9] Accounts of excitonium. Wikipedia: excitonium Wikipedia: exciton
- ^ [10] Accounts of superionic ice. Wikipedia: superionic water Wikipedia: Laboratory for Laser Energetics
Discussion
Log in with