People keep trying to fix the calendar, from Caesar's 445-day year and Sweden's February 30 to ten-day weeks, 13-month years and five-day Soviet weeks. The calendar seems like one of the most stable parts of daily life. Months, weeks and leap years appear to be fixed facts. In reality, the calendar most of the world uses today is the product of centuries of reform, and many people have tried to replace it with something they believed was more logical.
The basic problem is astronomical. A solar year lasts about 365.2422 days, which does not divide neatly into days, weeks or months. The cycles of the Moon add another complication. Any calendar has to compromise, and every compromise leaves someone unhappy.
The ten attempts below are the Julian calendar, the Gregorian reform, Sweden's unusual double switch, the French Republican calendar, Auguste Comte's Positivist calendar, the International Fixed Calendar, the World Calendar, the Soviet experiments with shorter weeks, the Revised Julian calendar and the modern Hanke-Henry proposal.
Some of these reforms succeeded and now shape billions of lives. Others were used for a few years and then abandoned, and some never got beyond proposals. Each shows how difficult it is to change something that touches religion, business, law and habit all at once.
The dates and details are drawn from standard histories of timekeeping. Calendar history is complicated, and dates sometimes differ depending on which calendar is being used to record them, so the years given here are approximate where necessary.
Key Facts
| # | Calendar | Main idea | Years in use or proposed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Julian calendar | A solar year of 365 days with a leap day every four years | Introduced 45 BC |
| 2 | Gregorian calendar | Dropped ten days and changed the leap year rule | Introduced 1582 |
| 3 | Swedish calendar | A gradual switch that went wrong | 1700 to 1712, with a switch in 1753 |
| 4 | French Republican calendar | Twelve months of thirty days, with ten-day weeks | 1793 to 1805 |
| 5 | Positivist calendar | Thirteen months of 28 days named after historical figures | Proposed 1849 |
| 6 | International Fixed Calendar | Thirteen months of 28 days and a Year Day | Proposed 1902; used at Kodak until 1989 |
| 7 | World Calendar | Equal quarters and a Worldsday outside the week | Proposed 1930; debated in the 1950s |
| 8 | Soviet calendar | A continuous working week with staggered rest days | 1929 to 1940 |
| 9 | Revised Julian calendar | A leap rule more accurate than the Gregorian | Proposed 1923 |
| 10 | Hanke-Henry Permanent Calendar | A 364-day year with an extra week every few years | Proposed in the 2000s and 2010s |
1. The Year of Confusion
Before Julius Caesar's reform, the Roman calendar had drifted badly out of line with the seasons. It depended on officials adding extra months when needed, and political interests often interfered with the process [1].
Advised by the astronomer Sosigenes of Alexandria, Caesar introduced a new solar calendar of 365 days, with an extra day every fourth year. To realign the calendar with the seasons, the year 46 BC was extended to 445 days, and it became known as the year of confusion [1].
The Julian calendar took effect in 45 BC and was used across the Roman world and later throughout Christian Europe. It was a great improvement, but it assumed a year of exactly 365.25 days, slightly longer than the real solar year, so it drifted by about one day every 128 years.
2. Ten Days That Disappeared
By the sixteenth century, the Julian calendar had drifted about ten days from the seasons, which affected the calculation of Easter. Pope Gregory XIII issued a decree in 1582 introducing a reformed calendar, based largely on proposals by the physician Aloysius Lilius and refined by the astronomer Christopher Clavius [2].
In Catholic countries, Thursday, October 4, 1582, was followed directly by Friday, October 15. The leap year rule was also changed: century years would be leap years only if divisible by 400, so 1600 and 2000 were leap years but 1700, 1800 and 1900 were not [2].
Related: Top 10 Calendars That Changed How People Count Time
Protestant and Orthodox countries adopted the reform much later. Britain and its colonies switched in 1752, when September 2 was followed by September 14. Greece adopted it for civil purposes in 1923. Today the Gregorian calendar is the world's main civil calendar.
3. February 30
Sweden planned to move from the Julian to the Gregorian calendar gradually, by skipping leap days over a forty-year period starting in 1700. It did skip the leap day in 1700, but then, partly because of the Great Northern War, it failed to skip the leap days in 1704 and 1708 [3].
As a result, Sweden's calendar was out of step with both the Julian and Gregorian calendars. To fix the problem, the government decided to return to the Julian calendar, and in 1712 it added two leap days to February, creating a February 30, a date that appears on very few calendars in history [3].
Sweden finally adopted the Gregorian calendar in 1753, when February 17 was followed directly by March 1. The episode shows how even well-planned reforms can go wrong when circumstances change.
4. Ten-Day Weeks and Poetic Months
During the French Revolution, the new government wanted to break with the monarchy and the church. In 1793 it introduced a calendar that dated years from the founding of the republic in September 1792 [4].
Each year had twelve months of thirty days, divided into three ten-day weeks called decades, plus five or six extra days at the end. The poet Fabre d'Eglantine gave the months names based on nature and the seasons, such as Brumaire for the foggy month and Thermidor for the hot month. Each day was named after a plant, animal, mineral or tool [4].
The ten-day week meant only one day of rest in ten instead of one in seven, which was unpopular. Napoleon abolished the calendar, and France returned to the Gregorian calendar at the start of 1806. The names Thermidor and Brumaire survive in historical terms for political events.
5. Months Named After Great Thinkers
The French philosopher Auguste Comte, founder of the philosophy called positivism, proposed a new calendar in 1849. It had thirteen months of twenty-eight days each, plus one or two extra days [5].
Related: Top 10 Complicated Ways People Used to Tell Time
Each month was named after a great figure in human history, including Moses, Homer, Aristotle, Archimedes, Caesar, Saint Paul, Charlemagne, Dante, Gutenberg, Shakespeare, Descartes, Frederick the Great and the physiologist Bichat. Every day was also dedicated to a notable person [5].
Comte saw the calendar as part of a new Religion of Humanity that would honor human achievement. It was used by some of his followers, but it never gained wide adoption. It did, however, inspire later proposals for thirteen-month calendars.
6. Thirteen Months at Kodak
The British-born railway statistician Moses Cotsworth proposed the International Fixed Calendar in 1902. It had thirteen months of exactly four weeks, with an extra month called Sol between June and July, and an extra day at the end of the year belonging to no week [6].
Because every month had the same length, each date would always fall on the same day of the week. Cotsworth argued this would make business accounting and planning much simpler. The League of Nations considered the idea among other calendar proposals in the 1920s [6].
The calendar's most famous supporter was George Eastman, founder of the Eastman Kodak Company. Kodak used the International Fixed Calendar for internal accounting from 1928 until 1989, long after the idea had faded elsewhere.
7. A Calendar Before the United Nations
In 1930, the American reformer Elisabeth Achelis founded the World Calendar Association to promote a perpetual calendar. It kept twelve months but divided the year into four equal quarters of ninety-one days. An extra day at the end of each year, called Worldsday, would belong to no week [7].
The proposal gained support from several governments and was discussed by the United Nations in the 1950s. Supporters argued it would make dates predictable and simplify business planning [7].
Related: Top 25 Interesting Facts About the Solar System
The plan stalled after opposition, including from the United States, which in 1955 said it could not support it. Religious groups objected that inserting a day outside the week would disrupt the seven-day cycle of Sabbath observance. The World Calendar has remained a proposal ever since.
8. Five-Day Weeks in the Soviet Union
In 1929, the Soviet Union introduced a continuous working week known as the nepreryvka. Factories would run every day, and workers were divided into groups, each with a different rest day in a five-day cycle [8].
The goal was to increase industrial output and weaken the influence of religion by eliminating the shared Sunday rest day. But families and friends often had different days off, which made social life difficult, and machines suffered from constant use [8].
In 1931, the system was changed to a six-day week with a common rest day. The seven-day week was restored in 1940. The Soviet experiment remains one of the boldest attempts to change the rhythm of the week.
9. An Even More Accurate Leap Year Rule
In 1923, the Serbian scientist Milutin Milankovic proposed a reformed calendar to Orthodox church leaders meeting in Constantinople. It was designed to bring the church calendar back into line with the seasons without adopting the Catholic Gregorian calendar directly [9].
Under its rule, century years are leap years only if dividing them by 900 leaves a remainder of 200 or 600. This makes it slightly more accurate than the Gregorian calendar over the long term. The two calendars will agree on every date until the year 2800 [9].
Several Orthodox churches, including those of Constantinople and Greece, adopted the Revised Julian calendar for fixed feasts such as Christmas, while others kept the old Julian calendar. The result is that Orthodox Christians celebrate some holidays on different dates.
Related: Top 25 Interesting Facts About the Universe
10. A Permanent Calendar for the Digital Age
The Hanke-Henry Permanent Calendar was developed by the economist Steve Hanke and the astronomer Richard Conn Henry of Johns Hopkins University. It uses a 364-day year, which divides evenly into fifty-two weeks [10].
Every year, each date falls on the same day of the week, so holidays and birthdays never move. To keep in line with the seasons, an extra week is added every five or six years. The authors argue that this would simplify scheduling and financial calculations [10].
The proposal has attracted media attention and some academic interest, but no country has adopted it. Like earlier perpetual calendar proposals, it faces the problem that changing the calendar requires agreement from many governments, businesses and religious communities.
Conclusion
These attempts show how hard it is to change the calendar. The scientific problem is difficult enough, but the social and religious problems are even greater. A calendar shapes holidays, contracts, religious observances and daily routines, and people resist changing all of them at once.
The successful reforms, such as Caesar's and Gregory's, had powerful authorities behind them. Even then, it took centuries for the Gregorian calendar to spread across the world. More radical reforms, such as ten-day weeks and thirteen-month years, have struggled to last.
The calendar we use today is far from perfect, but it is good enough for most purposes. That may be the strongest reason why it has survived so many attempts to replace it.
- ^ [1] Accounts of the Julian calendar. Wikipedia: Julian calendar Wikipedia: Sosigenes of Alexandria
- ^ [2] Accounts of the Gregorian calendar. Wikipedia: Gregorian calendar Wikipedia: Calendar (New Style) Act 1750
- ^ [3] Accounts of the Swedish calendar. Wikipedia: Swedish calendar Wikipedia: February 30
- ^ [4] Accounts of the French Republican calendar. Wikipedia: French Republican calendar Wikipedia: Fabre d'Eglantine
- ^ [5] Accounts of the Positivist calendar. Wikipedia: Positivist calendar Wikipedia: Auguste Comte
- ^ [6] Accounts of the International Fixed Calendar. Wikipedia: International Fixed Calendar Wikipedia: Moses B. Cotsworth
- ^ [7] Accounts of the World Calendar. Wikipedia: World Calendar Wikipedia: Elisabeth Achelis
- ^ [8] Accounts of the Soviet calendar. Wikipedia: Soviet calendar Wikipedia: week
- ^ [9] Accounts of the Revised Julian calendar. Wikipedia: Revised Julian calendar Wikipedia: Milutin Milankovic
- ^ [10] Accounts of the Hanke-Henry calendar. Wikipedia: Hanke-Henry Permanent Calendar Wikipedia: calendar reform
Discussion
Log in with